PDA

View Full Version : Rubber change or stay with the same?



Rhydian
06-17-2011, 07:50 AM
Hey guys,

Actually I play with Tenergy 05 on my forehand and Coppa J.O Platin on my backhand.
It's time for me to change rubbers.
Here comes my playing style:

Forehand:
I'm practicing forehand serves so in the future I'll do more forehand serves.
When the ball comes short, there's two possibilities: I give back short or I give a strong push to my opponents body (I can't flick ^^ but I'll practice it ^^)
When the ball comes long, with very much underspin, I play a spinny topspin (good placed) on the table. When the ball comes with not so much underspin I try to get my opponent under pressure and try do make the point.
When the opponent attacks, if I can't counter attack, I'll block ^^

Backhand:
At the moment I do more backhand serves than forehand serves. My serves should get a lot of spin.
My backhand is a little more passive than my forehand.
When the ball comes short, I try to flick or I give back short or I push hard (the same with forehand).
As I'm practicing my backhand topspin, when the ball comes long, I try to play a spinny backhand topspin. When I don't, then I play an effective push.
I block really good with my backhand. The countertopspin is in progress ^^

That's my play in general. I think you probably know that my backhand is the construction zone ;)

Suited rubbers:
I haven't found yet but as I go searching, I'll post my suggestions here and wait for your critical argumentation :)
You can also recommend some rubbers, that would be very kind,
Don't recommend Tenergy. It's a good rubber but too expensive ^^

Cheers :)

P.S.: my blade is Stiga Optimum SYNC (if you want, go see the thread I've posted in the blade section and help me out there aswell :)

azlan
06-17-2011, 01:12 PM
I'm more bias towards Stiga & Xiom, therefore I'm suggesting you Stiga Boost (FH) and Xiom Vega Pro (BH). There are a few Boosts that you may choose, from Boosts TS (softest) to TX (hardest). I find they offers excellent control. Same goes to Xiom..price wise, they are very competitive and offers good value for money.
My blades are Optimum Carbo and NCT Hybrid from Stiga.

Anders
06-17-2011, 03:01 PM
If you are able to, get some booster and a pair of Donic Gallardo Sounds to put on your blade :)

If not, go with Azlans suggestion. Personally I like Calibra Sound best for the backhand, and Boost TX for the forehand.

azlan
06-18-2011, 01:17 PM
Interesting Anders, and since you are using both Calibra and Boost, I'm just wondering if you may give me some insights on the these 2 rubbers, the Boosts TP and Calibra LT. I'm thinking of changing my Boosts TP (FH) to Calibra LT, not so much as to improve my game, but out of curiosity. Any views from anyone will be appreciated in fact, especially those who are very familiar with these rubbers. Thx

Rhydian
06-18-2011, 03:43 PM
Thanks!
I've made a list of rubbers that I might choose. Your (azlan's) suggestion is also there.
Here it goes:
Xiom:
- Omega IV Europe
- Vega Elite
- Vega Pro

Andro:
- Hexer

Donic:
- Acuda S2
- Acuda S3
- Coppa
- Coppa J.O. Platin

Joola:
- Brave
- Express 2
- Express x-plode
- Phenix

DHS:
- Neo Skyline 2 TG2

Stiga:
- Boost TX
- Boost TS
- Magna TS II

Which of them are the best suited?
Personnaly I thought about:
Backhand: Donic Acuda S3 (or maybe S2), Stiga Boost TS, Xiom Vega Pro (isn't that too fast for my not so good Backhand?)
Forehand: Xiom Vega Pro, Donic Coppa J.O Platin, Joola X-Plode, Stiga Magna TS II

Cheers :)

azlan
06-19-2011, 06:21 AM
Thats quite an extensive selection, and I enjoyed looking through the lists. But I'm wondering if you or anyone can give me the characteristics of Calibra LT in comparison with Boosts TP & TX.....Seems that Stiga will be launching Calibra LT Spin & Calibra LT Plus soon.

Rhydian
06-19-2011, 12:10 PM
Well, it's my first selection. I'm going to take some away after reading reviews and so on. Sorry azlan but I don't know these rubbers.. I hope someone here can tell us something about them :)

Anders
06-19-2011, 06:11 PM
The Calibra LT Sound and Calibra LT has a longer trajectory so that you can stand far away from the table and still hit really fast balls with tons of spin.

Boost TP = very hard sponge

Boost TX = Medium hard sponge

Calibra LT = Medium sponge

Calibra LT Sound = Soft sponge


Personally I like the TX best for the forehand because its the one with the most spin amongst the four rubbers mentioned. It also has excellent touch when serving.

The Calibra LT Sound suits my backhand nice because I can do anything with it. Super offensive, defensive, block, push, flick, loop, anything.

I do not know your style Azlan, so I cant say if it fits you.. But if you are about to switch from TP to a rubber that is a tad softer, start with the TX so that the change is not too big :)

Rhydian
06-19-2011, 09:29 PM
After the first round of struggling with myself, I came up with these here:

Donic:
- Acuda S2

Xiom:
- Omega IV Europe
- Vega Pro

Stiga:
- Boost TS

Joola: I don't find many reviews from these rubbers. Maybe some of you can help me?
- Brave
- Express 2
- Express X-Plode
- Phenix

At the moment, I'm tending to:
FH: Xiom Omega IV Europe or Vega Pro (and maybe Joola Express X-Plode but I don't find many reviews..)
BH: Donic Acuda S2, Stiga Boost TS

What do you think?
Do you know another rubber that I didn't mention and which can suit me? Then tell me :D

olvarox
06-19-2011, 10:55 PM
You have a personal grudge with Tibhar?
I play Tibhar and I love their rubbers.

Nothing personal, just curious why Tibhar is excluded from your list...

DustinZ
06-19-2011, 11:04 PM
Look into Tibhar Genius. It is fairly cheap on Amazon and I play it on both forehand and backhand. It has a slightly tacky topsheet that I can get a lot of spin on serves and its perfect for mid distance off the table loops. I used to use Tibhar Nimbus before this and Geospin tacky before that and so far this has been the best rubber I've had.

azlan
06-20-2011, 06:42 AM
Actually, its kinda true rhydian, tibhar have some really good rubbers which are right up your alley. You should definitely try genius and nimbus along with xiom vega.

Btw, thx Anders. It was very good info that you gave me. About my game, I'm all out offence. 2nd and 3rd ball attack. Anything slightly high or long, I will attack. I like playing a couple of feet away frm the table, or really far, and will try to finish the points asap. So far, my game is fine, just that I wanna try out the Calibra LTs. I have a looping BH, but my FH is sharp, keeping the ball low a couple of cm above the net, regardless how far I am from the table. I have a full swing FH, and it's always 110%... :-)

Rhydian
06-20-2011, 08:10 AM
Well I don't know much about Tibhar rubbers... That's why ^^
So, you propose: Tibhar Genius and Tibhar Nimbus ?
I'll take a look ;)

GianniiD
06-20-2011, 08:44 AM
Hi ,,

I have also a really offensive play style ,, i am verry happy with a tenergy 05 1.9 fot the FH ad my BH i play with a Genius , these rubber on my hinoke V is the perfect combination for a offensive playstyle ;D

Rhydian
06-20-2011, 09:43 AM
Hi,
I'm also happy with my Tenergy 05 but it'^s too expensive for me, so I want to change it ^^
Do you play the normal Genius? How is it? I've been looking around and got interested in the Genius + Optimum. Does anyone know something about this rubber?

Bollforte94
06-20-2011, 10:08 AM
so Rhy I can help you I play the normal Genius on my fh it is a very good rubber for loops and topspins
the balljump ( i dont know the english expression, hope you understand) is very high like the tenergy 05
you can get a lot of spin in your serves and topspins, a little bit less than t05 but no rubber can produce so much spin like the t05 atm

the difference between normal genius and genius +optimum: the normal genius has a higher ball jump and so it's better for topspins against backspin, the consequence is that the optimum rubber is better for counterloops (still the optimum has a high ball jump but not that high like the normal genius)

besides I would test the Tibhar Aurus( never tested it but read about it in a german forum and it get amazing reviews! really)
it is a topspin rubber and very good for all kinds of topspins (against backspin, block, for countertopspin)
the balljump is a little bit flatter than t05 spin is very good

comparison:

balljump: Genius >= T05 > Aurus
Spin : T05 >= Aurus > Genius ( but with all rubbers high spin is possible)
dynamic: Aurus = Genius > T05
Speed : Topspin: T05 fastest Genius and Aurus very fast too (if you have the right technique you will get the most spin with T05)
Hardness: Aurus>T05>Genius (Genius is medium)

so the Aurus is a newer version of the genius with a lower ball jump but good for all kinds of topspins and it is very hard

--> If I were you I would test the Genius and Aurus

Rhydian
06-20-2011, 10:43 AM
Thanks! The Aurus sounds really good. If I'm not mistaken, the Aurus Sound is a little bit softier than the Aurus ?

Again, I proceeded through elimination of rubbers and the remaining are:
Xiom:
- Omega IV Europe
- Vega Pro

Donic:
- Acuda S2

Joola:
- X-plode

Stiga:
- Boost TS

Tibhar;
- Aurus or Aurus Sound

Do you know something about the durability of these rubbers?
Hm, which ones should I pick...
What would you propose? Which one for FH and BH?

Cheers :)

YosuaYosan
06-20-2011, 01:41 PM
Try Aurus on both side bro :)

Anders
06-20-2011, 06:26 PM
Azlan: Glad to hear I can help you :) Your playing style sounds just as myself, all out offence. I would recommend the Calibra LT Sound for the backhand, because you can do almost anything you want to with this rubber. For my forehand, I like Boost TX the best, it does not have the same type of trajectory as the Calibra, but its still quiet fast and has excellent touch in the short-short game to! And of course, lots of spin :P

olvarox
06-20-2011, 07:43 PM
Hi

I just received my first Aurus Soft rubber, trying it out coming Thursday or Friday (been training 3 days in a row now and I'm exhausted :) )

I play Aurus Sound 2.1 on FH now and 1.9 on BH and I'm very pleased with it. I wonder how the Soft will feel compared to the 'sound' version.
The cool thing about the Aurus is the price! At €36.90 it's certainly one of the cheapest European New Generation Rubbers around.
For my full review on the Aurus sound, check this thread: http://www.tabletennisdaily.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?929-A-Tibhar-Aurus-Sound-review-for-you-all

Rhydian
06-20-2011, 07:51 PM
Thanks! :) Yeah, I've read it! Nice review! Waiting for the review with the Aurus Soft, an interesting rubber ;)

Maybe I'll buy some rubbers instead of only two and try different things out. Only problem getting on my way, is my mother xD

azlan
06-22-2011, 05:21 AM
Cheers Anders, well its decided then...I'm changing to calibra LT sound (confirmed) for BH and Boosts TP/TX (haven't decided for this yet). I'll be trying out TX this weekend, on my club mate's blade. Not playing this week, since I just finished a 3day tournament over the weekend. It was a team event, 3 singles..lost in the semis 1-2, but won 3rd place overall. Thx again buddy.

azlan
06-22-2011, 05:25 AM
Rhydian...that's a major hurdle for you, it's like getting approval from the sponsors, except it's 10 times harder. hahahaha good luck. BTW, excellent choice of rubbers. Hopefully, your blade won't act as if it was possessed anymore since she's getting new rubbers!! hehehe

Rhydian
06-22-2011, 06:50 AM
Thanks ^^
I made a pause and didn't look at my selection for a certain time. Then, when I look now or later, I'll surely find things that I don't like and so on and finally, I get the rubbers :D
(A friend of mine told me that he is sponsered by Joola and has 50% off so maybe I'll buy Joola X-Plode anyway and two or another rubber more but lets see ^^)
If someone still has ideas and can tell me something about the rubbers, please do it :)

YosuaYosan
06-22-2011, 02:38 PM
Please have this in mind :
Staying with the same rubber is still a good choice (but seeing your previous set, its quite expensive and the 'mom' barrier also lol)..
New rubber could mean new technique, new approach, new problems..

Its good to try things out but I think borrowing from your pals to see whether it suits you is a better idea, dont forget to see the rubber attached to the rubber you try to.
Good luck, God bless and have fun in your search..

Anders
06-22-2011, 04:37 PM
Glad to hear Azlan, good luck with your new rubbers :)

DustinZ
06-22-2011, 05:11 PM
If you are still thinking about trying Nimbus I forgot about its durrability factor. It doesn't last very long, and that was pretty disappointing. I'd say within about a 4 month period I found myself having to put a lot more effort innto my shots to get the same results as when it was new and it wsa chipping around the edges like crazy. It definitely lost its "pop", but so far the Genius has held up phenominally, and I've had to reglue it about 4 times over the past 7 months due to aggressive pushes that caught the rubber and peeled it up (but the rubber saw no damage or chipping!)

Rhydian
06-23-2011, 01:31 PM
Thanks!
@YosuaYosan: That's why I want to change ^^

I think I'm going to buy the two Xiom rubbers. In fact, while I was in the tournament in Belgium, I asked a player if he wanted to warm up with me and he said yes. He played the Xiom rubbers I mentionned. We changed blades and it felt really good! I really liked them! (His blade was also a xiom blade but I looked up and the difference to my blade was not much).
Guess who that guy was?
Jang WooJin. Actually ranked 36 on the ittf ranking for the U18 Players! Damn :O

What do you know about the durability of them?

azlan
06-23-2011, 03:40 PM
I use Xiom Vega Pro, and I have to say it's exceptional. It's a good rubber, but since I use Boost TP on my FH, it's 2 notch slower. The good thing about it is that it's very forgiving, and quite durable. You may stand far from the table, & hit a high looping topspin, and 9 times out of 10, the ball will find the table, with super top spin. Go for it!!

Rhydian
06-23-2011, 04:27 PM
Thanks Azlan!
I think I'll use Xiom Vega Pro for Forehand and Xiom Omega IV Europe for Backhand :)

Thanks to all of you :)

YosuaYosan
06-24-2011, 12:42 PM
Thanks Azlan!
I think I'll use Xiom Vega Pro for Forehand and Xiom Omega IV Europe for Backhand :)

Thanks to all of you :)

Nice setup there!
You could make bombs with that LOL :D

Hope you find your new setup the most comfortable and suitable to your natural playing style !

Stian
06-25-2011, 08:21 PM
I hope you will get comfortable with your new setup