Back to Forum

Poll: Did the ball touch the edge?

Results 1 to 15 of 15
  1. TableTennisDaily is offline
    says TableTennisDaily 2,0 is live!
     
    Administrator 6,441 4,045
    TableTennisDaily's Avatar
    TableTennisDaily is offline
    says TableTennisDaily 2,0 is live!
     
    Administrator 4,045 6,441

    User Info Menu


    Oct 2010
    England
    4,045
    6,441
    22593
    Read 0 Reviews
    #1

    Did the ball hit the table? Huge controversy - World Cup 2017!

    The Women's World Cup final between Zhu Yuling and Liu Shiwen took place last night and sparked one of the most controversial points in history! Did the ball hit the edge? See for yourself in the video below:



    What do you think?

    The Following 5 Users Like TableTennisDaily's Post:

    ajtatosmano2, Cornel and 3 others

    Out Now: TableTennisDaily.com 2.0

  2. yoass is offline
    says modestly attempting kōhaiship of Jeul-Tak
     
    Master TTD Member 2,365 2,470
    yoass's Avatar
    yoass is offline
    says modestly attempting kōhaiship of Jeul-Tak
     
    Master TTD Member 2,470 2,365
    #2
    Seeing the zoomed-in slo-mo footage, I think it did graze the table very, very lightly. When viewing in real time I didn't think so, and had I refereed it the point would have been LSW's — based upon honest human observation.

    The Following 3 Users Like yoass's Post:

    ajtatosmano2, NextLevel and 1 other


  3. Xylit is offline
    says ┌П┐(°_°)┌П┐
     
    Senior TTD Member 731 568
    X
    Xylit is offline
    says ┌П┐(°_°)┌П┐
     
    Senior TTD Member 568 731
    #3
    I think it did touch the edge.

  4. Cornel is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Advanced TTD Member 434 438
    C
    Cornel is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Advanced TTD Member 438 434
    #4
    Adam Bobrow posted on facebook that after the match the ITTF video team reviewed this situation and came to the conclusion that it hit the table :

    Name:  Clipboard02.jpg
Views: 204
Size:  37.9 KB

    It's good that Zhu Yuling still managed to win the match because this could have been a crucial point.

    The Following 5 Users Like Cornel's Post:

    Suga D, Takkyu_wa_inochi and 3 others

    Last edited by Cornel; 10-30-2017 at 09:17 AM.

  5. langel is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Master TTD Member 1,028 2,136
    L
    langel is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Master TTD Member 2,136 1,028
    #5
    If you look the video frame by frame - every frame has several phases of the ball motion, and on one of the frames where the ball is near the edge you will see that the lowest ball phase is moved higher than the previous trajectory. So I think the ball touched the edge with a horse wind.

    The Following User Likes langel's Post:

    sanavasaraja


  6. ajtatosmano2 is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Elite TTD Member 1,001 1,302
    A
    ajtatosmano2 is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Elite TTD Member 1,302 1,001
    #6
    On the playback it's clear that the ball hit the edge.

  7. Tinykin is offline
    says , "the older I get, the craftier I become"
     
    Elite TTD Member 1,076 1,303
    Tinykin's Avatar
    Tinykin is offline
    says , "the older I get, the craftier I become"
     
    Elite TTD Member 1,303 1,076
    #7

    Use of mics for edge ball

    I once set up a microphone on a TT table for recording a video. It was amazing how clearly audible was a brush-type edge ball. Now I did this with equipment that cost less than 20GBP.
    Maybe the ITTF needs to consider something similar.

    Edit: come to think about it, that's probably one of the inputs that the ITTF video review team used to determine that the ball hit. So how do we get this info to the umpire in less than 30sec following a protest/query? In a cost effective way of course

    The Following 5 Users Like Tinykin's Post:

    ajtatosmano2, Cornel and 3 others

    Last edited by Tinykin; 10-30-2017 at 11:06 AM.
    My table tennis club in Bristol, England
    http://bristol-cssc-tabletennis.weebly.com/

  8. jamesmith is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Advanced TTD Member 162 325
    J
    jamesmith is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Advanced TTD Member 325 162

    User Info Menu


    Sep 2016
    Hong Kong
    325
    162
    786
    Read 0 Reviews
    #8
    yes for sure it hits the edge

  9. NextLevel is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Master TTD Member 13,401 9,089
    N
    NextLevel is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Master TTD Member 9,089 13,401

    User Info Menu

    #9
    In the first game at 5-4, there was another point which I felt that LSW won where the ball also hit the edge but no one noticed. In the end, these errors are part of table tennis. If we introduce reliable replay, let's use it, but if not, let the umpire's decision stand.

    The Following 4 Users Like NextLevel's Post:

    Cornel, Michal_Z and 2 others

    Cobra Kai TT Exponent - No mercy in this dojo, no matter your rating or the score. All spin, no power or footwork.

    "We don't rise to the level of our expectations, we fall to the level of our training" - Archilochus

  10. suds79 is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Senior TTD Member 1,170 853
    suds79's Avatar
    suds79 is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Senior TTD Member 853 1,170
    #10
    I don't know how we can say for sure on these angled playbacks if it hit the edge or not.

    Still, how does the ITTF not have replay and a video camera fixed on the edges at table height so we can clearly determine these things? Or simply use tennis's replay feature that they use. Quick & to the point.

    Seems so obvious that I can only assume will be part of the game in a year or two from now.
    Last edited by suds79; 10-30-2017 at 02:19 PM.

  11. ajtatosmano2 is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Elite TTD Member 1,001 1,302
    A
    ajtatosmano2 is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Elite TTD Member 1,302 1,001
    #11
    Quote Originally Posted by suds79
    I don't know how we can say for sure on these angled playbacks if it hit the edge or not.

    Still, how does the ITTF not have replay and a video camera fixed on the edges at table height so we can clearly determine these things? Or simply use tennis's replay feature that they use. Quick & to the point.

    Seems so obvious that I can only assume will be part of the game in a year or two from now.
    The ball changed it's direction, that's how we can say for sure

  12. Michal_Z is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Master TTD Member 1,283 3,077
    Michal_Z's Avatar
    Michal_Z is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Master TTD Member 3,077 1,283
    #12
    Quote Originally Posted by NextLevel
    In the first game at 5-4, there was another point which I felt that LSW won where the ball also hit the edge but no one noticed. In the end, these errors are part of table tennis. If we introduce reliable replay, let's use it, but if not, let the umpire's decision stand.
    I am sure that the ball you mentioned did touch the table.
    But this was blood for blood match!
    There were at least 10 edges or net quotes - and there was NONE apology!
    This was just brutal.
    And I think both - controversial and also the one you mentioned - both touched the table.
    Both should be confirmed by players that were closer to the hit.
    In this case - the universe was fair - it gave one point like this to ZYL, second to LSW.
    Only LSW got it at the setpoint..

  13. JHB is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Advanced TTD Member 207 430
    JHB's Avatar
    JHB is offline
    This user has no status.
     
    Advanced TTD Member 430 207
    #13
    If the players don't/can't agree, let the umpire call it and move on. Wtf else can you do ? Reminds me of a local league match I was once umpiring where I called a net service at 19-20 (yes, it was that long ago) and the woman who had served the ball simply refused to accept that the ball had touched the net. The game was held up for five minutes of argument until finally the receiver agreed to accept the score was now 20-20 so that we could get the match finished !! What I should have done (as team captain as well as umpire for that game) was to have abandoned the match and reported the b**** to the league, however in those days I was young and wimpish and caved in instead. I've never forgotten it though !

    The Following User Likes JHB's Post:

    Suga D

    Second/spare blade: Joola K7 with Tibhar Evolution MX-P (forehand) and MX-S (backhand)

  14. yoass is offline
    says modestly attempting kōhaiship of Jeul-Tak
     
    Master TTD Member 2,365 2,470
    yoass's Avatar
    yoass is offline
    says modestly attempting kōhaiship of Jeul-Tak
     
    Master TTD Member 2,470 2,365
    #14
    Quote Originally Posted by JHB
    […] let the umpire call it and move on.
    Yes, that’s how much of a nobrainer this should be. For the sakes of all concerned.

    I also happen to consider attempts to claim such lucky points to be in poor form. Conversely, though, I have no qualms about pointing such out on my disadvantage, sportsmanship in the end being a greater good than winning matches.

    (‘Show me a gracious loser, and I’ll show you a loser’, some insisted. I disagree. Show me an ungracious winner, and I’ll show you a pitiful human being, I’d rather state.)

    The Following 2 Users Like yoass's Post:

    JHB and thomas.pong


  15. TTHopeful is offline
    says Dima... Amazing...
     
    Master TTD Member 854 2,176
    TTHopeful's Avatar
    TTHopeful is offline
    says Dima... Amazing...
     
    Master TTD Member 2,176 854

    User Info Menu

    #15
    Looks like it touched! Time for ITTF to bring in hawk eye like Tennis?

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Create a new Topic:
Title is required.