I have already explained about all this as to why it is not cheating (if USATT knows beforehand whet these players are using) but it is only criminal & unhealthy cheating (according to ITTF) if players boost & are totally untsted chemically. I am not going in circles again.It's cheating because it against the rules, as set out by the sport's governing body. The fact that "everyone" knows the cheating is going on doesn't stop it from being cheating. In fact, even if every competitor in the event was cheating, that also doesn't stop it from being cheating...though it would perhaps remove the competitive advantage normally associated with cheating. If a player is boosting and hiding that fact, that too is cheating. Please note there is no inconsistency in my argument in that regard; doing anything that is against the rules is cheating. Please also note that I am passing no judgement or opinion over whether or not these rubbers should be illegal; I'm merely highlighting the fact that they are illegal under the current rules.
If you did not know USATT or any national association can modify rules & regulations as they wish in their own tournaments. There may be some international tournaments that need to strictly confirm to ITTF rules & regulations.
Obviously, you do not understand at all as to what I have been explaining over & over for past 25 years. The 7 rule changes by looper controlled ITTF since 1987 (to 2014) have severely tilted the field in favor of illegally boosted up two winged loopers. Even using high aspect ratio super long pips will not give any competitive advantage for choppers but will slightly reduce the tilt.I'm also unsure as to how this experiment could work to your advantage. Let's say a player or players did take you up on your challenge. There are three possible outcomes in terms of their performance using the illegal rubber:
1. They perform better with the illegal rubber than they ordinarily would do with their usual/approved rubber
2. They perform no better nor no worse with the illegal rubber than they ordinarily would do with their usual/approved rubber
3. They perform worse with the illegal rubber than they ordinarily would do with their usual/approved rubber
In the case of scenario 1, the ITTF's justification for the ban is demonstrated as the experiment will show that these rubbers do give the competitive advantage that has already been deemed to be unfair.
I have already challenged Ma Long to play challenge matches against Hou Yingchao & Chen Weixing to earn a right to play against the GOAT Joo Sehyuk, with everyone using unboosted 1.7mm inverted & with Hou & Chen using High Aspect Ratio Super long pips.
You also keep saying "illegal" when you refer to High Aspect Ratio Super Long pips. They are not “illegal”. They are just ITTF unapproved. ONLY the boosters & speed-glues are "illegal” because according to ITTF they are unhealthy & therefore violate local, state, national & international health code regulations & are also unethical because they violate IOC fair play codes with a tilted playing field & may even be illegal via USA civil rights violations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I plead to ITTF to ban all pips & anti to release & set free all of ITTF's political prisoners (choppers / defenders)