Carl the problem I have is whenever I setup a drill .. e.g I am going to attack forehand .. automatically my ready position after serve changes ... meaning if I know if I am going to loop back hand ........ have you encountered this problem and figured out to outsmart your brain on this .. i have tried doing random but its not effective ..
This is a good point. But if you do not know how to hit the stroke yet, just worry about getting the ball on the table and doing the right stroke. If you already know how to hit a loop against short underspin where you have to drop your racket under the table and have the edge of the table sort of measured so you just miss it to catch a ball that would bounce twice, attacking it with a real loop instead of flipping, then you might need something different where the person receiving serve is trying to throw you off by where he/she puts the ball. But if you have not perfected the technique of looping then don't worry that you are set up for the shot you know is coming.
On the positive side of this issue, I also notice that if I set up for a forehand loop, I can cover the whole table with my forehand or switch to my backhand as I choose. An example, if I set up for a forehand loop and see the ball is coming to my backhand I can keep that set position and take a big one step deep to my backhand side and take the ball with my forehand. This is an important skill to have. I also notice that if I am set up for my forehand and it goes to my backhand, I have plenty of time to switch, setup for, and then take the ball with my backhand. If I have set up for backahnd and it comes to my forehand side, I am not as good at switching to forehand, but I can cover a good part of the forehand side of the table with my backhand as well.
So, even though this happens, it ultimately is not something to worry to much about. If you watch the pros, they have often decided what shot they are going to hit before the ball is coming and then they just need to use footwork to get into position.
So at a certain point it is worth being able to do that. Drills like the Faulkenberg and a 1-2-3-2-1 forehand drill help you be able to move from backhand to forehand on the backhand side. And again, it really ends up just being a matter of practice.
Last week I played some people at a bar near my home, instead of the guys I normally play at my club, the ball felt like it was going so slowly that I could cover the whole table with either my forehand and my backhand and I could feel how easy and natural the footwork was at that speed. I don't think these people had ever seen anything like it, but it was nice for me to see that the footwork happened naturally since, usually I am playing people better than me where I get stuck with stuff like that. The guys I play who are better than me seem to be able to handle what ever I throw at them the same way, like it is easy and in slow motion.
More practice but the right practice. When you have exceeded the usefulness of a drill you might need new ones. And drills should never replace match play. Drills teach you skills and help you change habits you fall into in match play that are holding you back. Match play shows you when you have sufficiently learned those skills so that you are naturally using good technique when the situation you drilled on comes up in a match.