In my opinion a lot of what's touched on this thread is just a summary of why equipment reviews are alllllll over the place with disagreements. "pfft, you think THIS rubber can generate more spin than THIS rubber, whatever bro!" but that's reality for some people. Hearing about Dodean and maybe not wanting to use 09c anymore is a perfect example. What works for your capabilities is vastly different to what might work for the next person's capabilities.
I finally got to try 09c and immediately knew it was not for me. Yeah, I thought it could do great things. When I really accelerated into the ball like I can, it's an amazing ball and I thought the rubber felt great. When I give my average quality forehand though, I just don't get anything extra out of it compared to any other rubber and the feel is not there at all. Plus it's way less forgiving. If I get my forehand to be sharp enough to justify the hard/tacky stuff again, I also just don't see what something like that has to offer over hurricane or something.
I'm using G1 max right now on my forehand and since my average quality can take full advantage of it, It is a very consistent and reliable rubber for me with a ton of spin and plenty of power. My average forehand delivers a ball that is higher quality with G1 than if I play something like 09c. The only way that's not true is if I'm really just using thin contact exclusively, but I don't do that and that's also not the point of hard/tacky rubber. I avoided using G1 initially because it was a 'boring' pick and all the new exciting stuff out there seemed more interesting, but dang if it doesn't still hold up.