Existing Hurricane 3 2.7mm Version, how will DHS compete against Zyre? Hurricane 3 VS Z03 Rant

There's a rubber called Haitian Hippocampus speed 2.1mm, which had a review by Roning Team 5 years ago and it was shown to play exactly like Hurricane 3, but with ever so slightly less spin and a lower throw angle and a bit more elastic. It is probably the closest, and cheapest clone there is on the Chinese market. Now the same company Haitian has released an identical version of the rubber now copying the trend of Z03 thickened sponge thinned topsheet with a 2.7mm version which in my opinion seems to offer a solution to Hurricane 3 vs Z03.

Hurricane 3 requires more effort to use compared to Z03 to get probably 10-20% extra spin (although they are near in difficulty Z03 is significantly less), and Zyre has way higher base speed, but offers less control. Not to mention, Hurricane 3 is becoming increasingly more grippy and less tacky pushing appeal away from DHS players like myself. The advantage H3 still has in my opinion is that you have greater options for selecting hardness, and that you can in different methods to your preferences, but of course durability is less and effect only lasts so long having a comparable price to Z03 in the long run to use it optimally. Also Hurricane 3 has a really pronounced 2nd gear kick effect when you loop through it properly as well as the ball dropping much quicker. Although, the game is become much faster, rubbers getting harder, pros are switching, and arcs are getting longer. Anyways all this aside, how will hurricane realistically compare to Z03 when the game gets quicker, and speed is more important than spin nowadays, and athleticism will cost you. What will Hurricane X bring? Pores in the topsheet, different layering of pores in the sponge for different styles of contact, many hypothetical ideas are yet to be explored, but can DHS even compete with Butterfly at this point? Z03 has also created a revolution as D09C did with hybrid rubbers where all other brands will follow, but of course at less durability. It also makes me think about outer carbon VS inner carbon, especially core material. Kiri dampens and the koto outer gives easy speed, Fan Zhendong proved that H3 doesn't need the dwell of an inner unless you will use the athleticism to hit the blade very hard absolutely every time, but you will suffer in the backhand, and wing transitions.

Anyways back to the subject at hand, Haitian Hippocampus seems to offer a solution Hurricane 3 should've had all along. The only way to give H3 can get more speed is by A: boosting more (although we know theres an extent until it feels mushy) or B: switch to a faster blade (lose control, and brushing isn't as effective). Both have disadvantages that are flawed against H3. This doesn't even mention that what the pros get is a lot tackier, and more controlled (we know based off Dan's TTD vid). 2.7mm sponge still gives that deadness on touch shots and control, but gives extra add on speed while retaining the H3 characteristics. I will be trying this rubber later next year after a friend's strong recommendation, and will give it a review. Butterfly has also with the release of Z03 perfectly enabled a rubber to fit within the speed of D09c and Z03, but spin and control of D09c at a lower throw angle, maybe this will be Zeed.

Curious to hear your guy's thoughts and sorry for the jumble of ideas!
 
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,141
1,944
6,312
Read 2 reviews
The actual star player H3 versions are individualized. I'm sure some of them are less tacky than commercial ones, and some of them are more tacky. Supposedly Ma Long has really tacky backhand especially. It's probably not the same for everyone else.

That probably goes for Zyre as well. BTY pro rubbers just aren't the same as the commercial ones, even more-so than DHS supposedly if you go by what pros say. Grippier, harder.

Butterfly rubbers are a better compromise for amateurs but I'm not convinced that large pores are ideal for performance. I think they're mostly there to make the sponge overall softer and more progressive so it's easier to use. I don't know how they relate to the actual elasticity/damping/hysteresis/flexibility etc.

ESN especially markets it like it's an ideal compromise for performance, but I don't really trust marketing.
 

K.K

This user has no status.

K.K

This user has no status.
Member
Aug 2024
396
422
1,110
i don't think there is a revolution going on. but i think that butterfly is somehow able to ramp up the quality for existing technologies in a way that they provide the edge for professional players and therefore have much more influence in what consumers will buy. what i mean ist that thick sponge/thin topsheet was already available with the max+ concept by esn that was around 2,4-2,5 mm sponge thickness. they just couldn't create the necessary spin like butterfly later did with zyre. same with hybrid, esn and the chinese manufacturers released so many hybrids way before butterfly did, but they where mostly bricks that felt more like boosted chinese rubbers and butterfly somehow found a better mix that stood out. i think butterfly is doing really well in the professional tt world and their rubbers are really good even though the price is high, but i was actually a bit confused why zyre did not meet the expectations they created, since a lot of pros came back to dignics after trying zyre out for a few events. in comparison: when they released dignics, tenergy basically died out.

@Archo i don't understand your comment, your saying the butterfly pro line is for amateur players? i would not advice any amateur player to buy pro equipment, not even tenergy
 
  • Like
Reactions: sebi
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,141
1,944
6,312
Read 2 reviews
@Archo i don't understand your comment, your saying the butterfly pro line is for amateur players? i would not advice any amateur player to buy pro equipment, not even tenergy
I'm saying Butterfly's commercial equipment is mostly made for ease of play and not maximum performance. The pro versions seem to edge the compromise more towards performance at the cost of being more demanding for input force.

Hurricane 3 is already pretty far in that direction, even in the softest commercial versions. The performance is high and more optimized in the higher input forces, which many people find difficult to use.
 
The actual star player H3 versions are individualized. I'm sure some of them are less tacky than commercial ones, and some of them are more tacky. Supposedly Ma Long has really tacky backhand especially. It's probably not the same for everyone else.

That probably goes for Zyre as well. BTY pro rubbers just aren't the same as the commercial ones, even more-so than DHS supposedly if you go by what pros say. Grippier, harder.

Butterfly rubbers are a better compromise for amateurs but I'm not convinced that large pores are ideal for performance. I think they're mostly there to make the sponge overall softer and more progressive so it's easier to use. I don't know how they relate to the actual elasticity/damping/hysteresis/flexibility etc.

ESN especially markets it like it's an ideal compromise for performance, but I don't really trust marketing.
Even though its star national QC I still think its dependent on what you get. I tried the Ma Long one the day it was glued on a friend's bat, absolutely no tackiness compared to when Dan said its super sticky. It was mostly grippy, but couldn't even lift the ball. This will still also not even compare to what Ma Long actually uses. The commercial can't compare and you're absolutely right. Interestingly Haitian offers a custom rubber service ITTF won't approve, but you can get it approved for a fairly cheap cost at a low individual rubber cost so could work out in the long run like pros getting own custom rubbers. I think we both agree on the stance with Butterfly, I prefer D09c on backhand, but plan to try H3 on backhand how do you find it? Large pores def not ideal and hippocampus is slightly larger than h3, but mostly thicker sponge. ESN durability too poor won't even consider ngl.
i don't think there is a revolution going on. but i think that butterfly is somehow able to ramp up the quality for existing technologies in a way that they provide the edge for professional players and therefore have much more influence in what consumers will buy. what i mean ist that thick sponge/thin topsheet was already available with the max+ concept by esn that was around 2,4-2,5 mm sponge thickness. they just couldn't create the necessary spin like butterfly later did with zyre. same with hybrid, esn and the chinese manufacturers released so many hybrids way before butterfly did, but they where mostly bricks that felt more like boosted chinese rubbers and butterfly somehow found a better mix that stood out. i think butterfly is doing really well in the professional tt world and their rubbers are really good even though the price is high, but i was actually a bit confused why zyre did not meet the expectations they created, since a lot of pros came back to dignics after trying zyre out for a few events. in comparison: when they released dignics, tenergy basically died out.

@Archo i don't understand your comment, your saying the butterfly pro line is for amateur players? i would not advice any amateur player to buy pro equipment, not even tenergy
I'm not very familiar with any max rubbers that are 2.5mm let alone 2.4mm, but yes the idea has been around. Ricosheet makes the idea especially interesting and offers a lot.

Here is Haitian:
 

Attachments

  • hr.jpg
    hr.jpg
    201.3 KB · Views: 13
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Oct 2019
2,368
1,356
4,759
Read 5 reviews
Sorry for replying more to the topic title than contents of the thread, but why should the reply in any way? They have their products that suit their players. DHS distro is mostly China market, they do not have much pressence in EU, and their rubbers are not really suitable for majority of the players here.

The TT crowd is weird. I think that a lot (I really mean a LOT), of the gear decisions is influenced by what you think the gear should be, instead of what it actually is. There was this guy from Korea who did fake W986 vs. real W986, and most people chose the fake one.

I wonder how many people would actually choose Zyre blindly. When TT11 did the blind test, it did not do that well.

For me the key takeaway is, no brand needs to clone Butterfly. If they want to compete with Butterfly, they need to spend more money on marketing :|
 

K.K

This user has no status.

K.K

This user has no status.
Member
Aug 2024
396
422
1,110
I'm saying Butterfly's commercial equipment is mostly made for ease of play and not maximum performance. The pro versions seem to edge the compromise more towards performance at the cost of being more demanding for input force.

Hurricane 3 is already pretty far in that direction, even in the softest commercial versions. The performance is high and more optimized in the higher input forces, which many people find difficult to use.
what are you talking about? butterfly dignics/tenergy/zyre is 100% pro equipment and maximum performance. i know professional players who are not sponsored anymore and just go to the any tt store and buy a sheet. even tenergy 05 is still one of the spinniest rubbers out there. yes sponsored players maybe get a harder sponge, but that is not the norm at all and if you need that for a boost in performance then you are in a level that only 0,1% of people are anyway.
maybe the rubbers you got where not genuine?

i know that on the chinese market you get different sponges for the same rubbers and can work your way up when you get better, but in the japanese and euro market you have different rubbers for that like at butterfly from sriver to rozena to tenergy and so on
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coolsta Connor
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,141
1,944
6,312
Read 2 reviews
@Coolsta Connor

The STAR National rubbers are IIRC based on the 2019 pro spec rubbers in basic params if DHS marketing is to go by. The actual real pro rubbers change between *every event* and sometimes *every match*. Based on the venue, the opponent and the player's condition. So it's hard to say what a Ma Long rubber even is. :)

I wouldn't say market versions can't compare, it's still almost the same in actual performance if ex-DHS sponsored pros are to go by. It doesn't seem as large of a difference as something like Tenergy SP or MX-P Pro.

I was surprised with H3 on backhand; I was expecting to be uber slow and really physical to use, but I didn't find that. Changing from a fast inner to Acoustic I still feel the same. It's not as powerful in my hands as Tenergy or Dignics (skill issue) but it's much more stable and controlled, pushes, blocks, counters are very damped and the risk of the ball flying out is much lower which for me is a benefit. Slow flicks and chops are easy due to the high grip. Opening loops have more spin than G1 and D05 and sometimes people block them out.
The speed range is very wide and it has that H3 2nd gear once you hit through it, even with my dogshit backhand. The 37A version is easier to smash with than harder blue sponge and I twiddle to it on high smashes; seems more accurate and faster.

I currently prefer it to H8-80, G-1, T05, D05 and so on. Maybe as my skills improve and speed becomes more important my opinion will change but it definitely has qualities to it.

@K.K
I think BTY pros are not allowed to talk about the rubbers. Many of them won't talk about it even after not being sponsored. Pros I know of who just don't give a fuck tend to say Tenergy SP and the team versions of Dignics are really different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coolsta Connor
says Shoo...nothing to see here. - zeio
says Shoo...nothing to see here. - zeio
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Jan 2018
14,128
13,513
31,115
It's rumored DHS has come up with a new pre-tuned H3, the one that JWJ used to win WTT CS Montpellier 2026.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coolsta Connor
Sorry for replying more to the topic title than contents of the thread, but why should the reply in any way? They have their products that suit their players. DHS distro is mostly China market, they do not have much pressence in EU, and their rubbers are not really suitable for majority of the players here.

The TT crowd is weird. I think that a lot (I really mean a LOT), of the gear decisions is influenced by what you think the gear should be, instead of what it actually is. There was this guy from Korea who did fake W986 vs. real W986, and most people chose the fake one.

I wonder how many people would actually choose Zyre blindly. When TT11 did the blind test, it did not do that well.

For me the key takeaway is, no brand needs to clone Butterfly. If they want to compete with Butterfly, they need to spend more money on marketing :|
I get where you're coming from and mostly agree, but your Korean guy example is true as I also watched the vid. The fake has ZLC instead of ALC and I reckon most people prefer a higher base speed as it resembles outer carbon blades more whereas W968 is actually more ideal for strong forehand loopers especially at mid distance which is less common to close distance. The reason I pick I think DHS needs to compete with zyre is because even in China, zyre and dignics 09C are starting to become very prevalent and it's not helping when even the Chinese national team players are switching. People in China have shown to really like zyre because it behaves near that of boosted hurricane without the "hassle", and it's more durable although of course the feel and touch isn't as advantageous, but some people like more springy and there's a definite shift that is happening within China where there seems to be no response from DHS. DHS currently is only still around in China because the majority of pro players use it, but the fact that's changing is very interesting. Of course the pros likely use a more grippy version which resembles the tackiness of the hurricane even more, but if you want to be competitive in a modern game you need to go for speed and that's just fact. Even as someone who loves hurricane I think that I need to boost it more to be competitive at times because the athleticism required is substantial and in China most people are now open to actually experimenting and changing as especially a lot of middle aged people aren't fit enough to use hurricane (plus creators promote tensor when you get older), but want to play the game seriously and they will get more performance out of zyre. The only advantage DHS has now is hurricane. Barely anyone uses DHS on backhand, DHS as blade is not as common as Butterfly, the S/Q968 spinoff's were a bit of a flop and W968 is still king, but even with the modern game Viscaria is the most common blade there is. DHS should respond
@Coolsta Connor

The STAR National rubbers are IIRC based on the 2019 pro spec rubbers in basic params if DHS marketing is to go by. The actual real pro rubbers change between *every event* and sometimes *every match*. Based on the venue, the opponent and the player's condition. So it's hard to say what a Ma Long rubber even is. :)

I wouldn't say market versions can't compare, it's still almost the same in actual performance if ex-DHS sponsored pros are to go by. It doesn't seem as large of a difference as something like Tenergy SP or MX-P Pro.

I was surprised with H3 on backhand; I was expecting to be uber slow and really physical to use, but I didn't find that. Changing from a fast inner to Acoustic I still feel the same. It's not as powerful in my hands as Tenergy or Dignics (skill issue) but it's much more stable and controlled, pushes, blocks, counters are very damped and the risk of the ball flying out is much lower which for me is a benefit. Slow flicks and chops are easy due to the high grip. Opening loops have more spin than G1 and D05 and sometimes people block them out.
The speed range is very wide and it has that H3 2nd gear once you hit through it, even with my dogshit backhand. The 37A version is easier to smash with than harder blue sponge and I twiddle to it on high smashes; seems more accurate and faster.

I currently prefer it to H8-80, G-1, T05, D05 and so on. Maybe as my skills improve and speed becomes more important my opinion will change but it definitely has qualities to it.

@K.K
I think BTY pros are not allowed to talk about the rubbers. Many of them won't talk about it even after not being sponsored. Pros I know of who just don't give a fuck tend to say Tenergy SP and the team versions of Dignics are really different.
We will never know what pros use you are right, and it variable ofc. I like the prospect of h3 on backhand for the control it offers, counters, and open ups, but I think I'd really have to boost it heavy as my backhand game is also very speed dependent. What is 37"A"? I currently use orange sponge on forehand (out of my choice), and it feels decent on backhand. The speed is just not enough for me though, D09c is elastic and clicky, may need something harder. I don't know tbh, I don't know.
.
 
Top