It seems your suggestion doesn't make any sense.
Michael opened the thread to discuss his technique. Although I said my question is not so much relevant to Michael, but it also means it does relevant to Michael. It is relevant to Michael and all others who are thinking about their use of waists..
If I use a video of SOMEONE ELSE, should I ask for the permission of someone else? Of course I should. Or do you just mean I can upload a video of someone else and raise a topic as I want, you think it is OK if this someone else is NOT a member of the forum? Some others did uploaded videos and people have discussed so many other things in a wide range, and you didn't said anything like above, it seems you are OK for that way.
All in all, the situation is that Michael opens the thread to everyone on the forum to discuss his technique. It is OK for everyone to discuss in relation to his technique IN HIS THREAD.
I didn't have to make long words before my raising the question, but I did and I apologized in advance. That was what I have done to show my consideration on Michael's feeling. If Michael said he didn't want me to discuss the use of hips, I will delete my question. I don't have to do that, but I will do. Being challenged is always not a happy thing, I have tried not be challenging to Michael, but it seems you didn't want to waste of your time to cover your challenging attitude towards me.
Going back to the question on use of hips. I raised the question because the use of hips is not so black and white. Everyone is turning waist more or less, but what we want is how we can effectively apply the energy of waist/hip to our stroke. I raise that question is because Michael was turning his waist but I have a feeling that the energy hasn't been fully transferred to racket. I am not so sure about my feeling, so I raise it. That is the difference between you and me, because you are so sure that he has used hip, and I think it requires further discussion.
The actual issue is, the way you raised the question was, whether you realize it or not, done in a way that was insulting. That you are still oblivious to this, I think, is unfortunate. If I say, I am sorry to say this, but you are a _______ (fill in something rude) I am still being rude. In fact the "I am sorry" before being rude seems to me to highlight the part that is rude.
And you could start the new thread about use of hips with a pro who is doing it well. Or you could start the thread about using hips with a VIDEO OF YOU. But, yes, if the example is of someone who is not using the hips effectively, then, it should either be you or someone who is purposely demonstrating ineffective use of the hips.
Further, you could ask things, WITHOUT REFERENCING VIDEO OF MICHAEL, or referring to anyone, and ask something like:
"this is a question for some of the higher level players: could you explain how one would use the hips in a way that makes the stroke more effective?" And something like that could have been anywhere including in this thread. Please note: I phrased that without referencing specific footage or player.
The answer is sort of that the hips should be timed to add power to the moment of contact. It can be a very small movement or a bigger movement, but if the hips pop in a way that is timed to transfer power into the ball on contact it will make the stroke and the transfer of energy into the ball more effective thus, making the shot a higher quality shot.
But, the way you phrased it made it seem like you were saying what Michael was doing was not effective. Which is probably part of why Michael commented after you that he is probably not using his hips effectively.
And there is a reason why Jammail made this comment:
jammmail;354167
And this is the reason why more people don’t post footage tbh (including myself) as the criticism isn’t always constructive.
There are a few good comments and they are invariably from players who are higher level and know what they are talking about and then there are a ton of comments that really are just kind of insulting that probably will go into the category of too much and irrelevant information.
Hips, it could be useful to discuss the function of hips. But why highlight something like that with reference to Michael's video when, that is definitely something that will just start happening as he practices more without him even focusing on it. As the skill and coordination of the stroke get refined from practice and repetition, the hesitance that is part of why the hips are not timed well, will go away and the stroke will be more confident. The pieces of the puzzle are actually mostly there for Michael. What he needs most is simply practice and repetition.