Blade broken in half, did this ever happen to you?

says Gucci gang, gucci gang, gucci gang, gucci gang, gucci...
says Gucci gang, gucci gang, gucci gang, gucci gang, gucci...
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Active Member
Jul 2014
884
796
3,998
I've only seen this happen once in my lifetime, on a Donic Defplay Senso, completely split down the same line starting near the handle, I assumed it happened because of the flexing stress the blade is put under especially being so thin. But this was after a year or two of usage.

Edit- now that I remember I've also had two Stiga Allround Classic blades and a Donic Dicon JO shape that I had to toss because they started cracking in the core and medial plies near the same spot as the split in OPs handle. They are all very thin 5 ply wood blades (like 5.5mm) and I assumed that they cracked because they are cheaply built and I like to hit hard. They were barely usable when the cracks became noticeable, but they didn't split all the way through to the top ply. This was also back during the cell ball era, repeated impact of the heavier and harder poly ball might also factor in
 
Last edited:
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
May 2011
1,964
2,290
5,443
Even if the core was jointed and weaker wouldnt the other two plies on each side kind of hold it together? My vote is also for outside interference...

Dave are there kids in your living/playing quarters that might've "played" with it unsupervised?
Exactly, has to be outside factor. Someone sat on it or stood on it or dropped something heavy on it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sims
This user has no status.
Not to distract from the subject or derail the thread, but I do want to dispel the general notion that a blade that features multiple pieces of wood in the core is necessarily inferior.

I make multi-ply blades which have both one piece cores, and multi-piece cores, and to suggest one or the other is inferior due to its build, just isn't true. Wood density generally differs a lot across a tree's cross section, so it's entirely possible (and frequently the case) to have a core made from one piece of wood, that is inherently weaker and softer on one side, due to simple and natural density shifts from sapwood to Heartwood.

If you use a piece of wood like this to make a blade, it won't flex or bounce right, and is far more likely to warp, because one side of the core is inherently weak.

If however you cut the weak section out, and then book match and butt-glue the two remaining pieces together, you can get a far superior core with even density, and consistent strength, grain, bounce and flex under load, and the butt glued section is actually far stronger than the rest of the wood would normally be.

It is frankly irrelevant if the core is made from one piece of wood, or multiple pieces. What matters is quality of material, quality workmanship, and consistent mechanical properties right across the end result. Good wood is always good wood, bad wood is always bad wood, and whether it's in one piece or several just doesn't matter.

It's actually very hard to make a bad blade from good wood (you've really got to stuff up badly to manage it), whereas it often doesn't matter how much you try to compensate for bad quality wood with extra craft, at the end of the day you're still trying to polish a turd, and you still get a shitty blade at the end of it.
 
Last edited:
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Jan 2024
12
7
28
There are no children in my proximity (not yet at least haha).

I probably have to accept that somehow, the blade got under a lot of pressure and decided to snap between sets.

Thanks to all of you, I guess this thread can be closed, as stated in the first post, I never doubted the craftmanship which is second to none.

Have a good one,
Dave
 
says Table Tennis - the sport for life.
says Table Tennis - the sport for life.
Member
Jan 2013
325
337
1,582
I've seen this type of damage before, it happened when some sat onto a chair when a bat (inside a flimsy case) was laying. Without the handle piece the pressure over the whole bat would be quite even, but the handle piece sticks out, making the pressure very uneven, and cracks in-line with the handle piece can happen.
In my case, the person that sat down owned up and apologised, and said that they could feel the bat cracking as they dropped themselves on the seat, and did not see that that bat & case was there because it was partially covered by a towel.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Sep 2023
272
230
1,807
I mean it’s hard to believe that this happened randomly. He also contacted OSP so I don’t think they’d even partially refund him
Yea, it's impossible to convince the manufacturer this happened w/o abuse. They hear so much garbage. Sucks for the OP, cuz it looked like a nice blade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robin0910 and Sims
says 2023 Certified Organ Donor
says 2023 Certified Organ Donor
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Sep 2011
13,220
13,863
31,594
Read 27 reviews
Some people may be inclined to declare this is a deep AI fake operation.

I had a really thin blade, maybe under 5 mm... I managed to crack this blade the same way in pretty much the same place vertically.

I made a big power loop and maybe stuck a tiny off center and bam, blade cracked.

I had to reimburse myself as at the time I sold the blade to myself.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Oct 2024
109
84
307
Meanwhile, in Australia, someone is asking how they can split a table tennis blade in half, to end up with TWO blades.

 
This user has no status.
Meanwhile, in Australia, someone is asking how they can split a table tennis blade in half, to end up with TWO blades.

HAD to reply to that Bunnings poster on reading this, and tell them not to attempt it.

The very thought of splitting a custom hand-made one-ply down the middle to get two useless unplayable halves... It just breaks your heart. 😭😭
 
  • Like
Reactions: PhoenixTT
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Oct 2024
109
84
307
HAD to reply to that Bunnings poster on reading this, and tell them not to attempt it.

The very thought of splitting a custom hand-made one-ply down the middle to get two useless unplayable halves... It just breaks your heart. 😭😭
Saw your awesome reply. You might have just stopped the guy from producing the world's first outer charcoal blade. Two of them.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Wakkibatty
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Active Member
Sep 2023
691
515
2,584
Some people may be inclined to declare this is a deep AI fake operation.

I had a really thin blade, maybe under 5 mm... I managed to crack this blade the same way in pretty much the same place vertically.

I made a big power loop and maybe stuck a tiny off center and bam, blade cracked.

I had to reimburse myself as at the time I sold the blade to myself.
jees.. is this AI bot still replying?
 
Hi guys,

so I am now struggling with the fact that my blade broke in half and I DO NOT KNOW HOW?!
I was drinking between sets and after I came back to the table, I noticed splinters on the handle and then saw a crack and then noticed that the crack actually covers the entirety of the blade...

My blade is barely 3 months old, I have not even touched a table with it, I did not step or sit on it, it has always been in a cover with other blades (I checked all of them, none have a similar problem to this)...
This is even a handmade blade which I loved very much, I would not bother this much about a BFY Primorac blade, but this one was special.

Any idea how this could have happened? I pay great attention to my blades and in my 20 years playing this sport, nothing like this has ever happened to me. Could this be a production error? I highly doubt this because the craftmanship is remarkable.


Maybe you encountered something similar yourselves?

Cheers David
My blade split in half but luckily it's split with the grain so I glued it back together and has been as good as new have you tried to glue it back together might be worth a try just need some wood glue!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wakkibatty
says Pimples Schmimples
says Pimples Schmimples
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Sep 2022
1,195
1,206
4,611
I
My blade split in half but luckily it's split with the grain so I glued it back together and has been as good as new have you tried to glue it back together might be worth a try just need some wood glue!!!
I have to say here that given what you've described I cannot believe your blade is as good as new. Maybe you cannot notice the difference but if a multi layer blade like that snaps as shown a simple bond of wood glue is not gonna restore it to the same characteristics it had before snapping.
Structurally, that would be impossible.
 
Top