I would argue there was no point to his argument except superficially. Consider this. There are literally thousands of table tennis rackets, sponges, and other equipment. But table tennis books only come out a few times a year. Suppose Ma Long, a national coach, or some other knowledgeable table tennis person who doesn’t normally post on this forum writes a new table tennis book. People come to this forum to get their table tennis news and discuss it. The key question is: Are they better off knowing about this new TT book, or kept ignorant? If they are better off knowing, then there really is no point to the idea that this person shouldn’t post about it because he hasn’t been posting here regularly.
I think it ultimately comes down to what’s more important: knowing about the new TT book from someone who’s contributed a lot to the TT community for decades and who’s put in a huge amount of time and effort on a TT project that many will benefit from . . . or punishing that author because he doesn’t post here regularly. (Keep in mind that out of all the many people who reacted or commented, all but one were positive, and the only one who objected did so with insults and dripping sarcasm.)
This is an important question for me. Around June 15 I have a rather different TT book coming out, “Ping-Pong Paddles Can’t Talk!” It’s a children’s picture book that features a nervous boy and his talking paddle in their first tournament, where he meets and plays a girl who is really good, and they have an adventurous match. Along the way, kids learn about the sport, with themes of facing your fears, working toward a goal, honesty, and friendship. It’s all told in humorous Seussian rhyme. Now, if there is reticence from even the forum moderators over whether it’s appropriate for me to let the forum know about it, then I simply won’t post about it here. Would the forum be better off that way? (
Here’s the cover!)
-Larry Hodges