Tibhar Bss vs victas SWAT vs sanwei fextra

[Celebration]

Hey guys can you compare these blades please.
I tried fextra and it is a bit too quick. Or compare it please to Xiom Offensiv s.
I need a blade to play all good. Topspin Block and short game

 

[rwk92]

Hi @Celebration, you can check ttgearlab for Bernadette Szocs Signature 1, Victas Swat, and Xiom offensive S as a starting point
Below are the links

BSS1:

Tibhar Bernadette Szöcs Signature 1 [Lab Test Report] (Updated on 12th October 2023)

Update Notice (12th October 2023) : The data of ‘InnerForce Layer ALC’ has been changed from that of 2018 version to newer 2023 version. ‘InnerForce Layer ALC’s measured in …

ttgearlab.com

Victas Swat:

Victas Swat Power [Photos & Information]

‘Victas’ is a recently introduced Japanese table tennis brand. It had originally been ‘TSP’ that is the traditional Japanese brand, and one of the biggest table tennis brand…

ttgearlab.com

Xiom offensive S:

Xiom Novus series [TTGearLab Works]

Work of TTGearLab for theses equipments : (1) The concept of blade family (2) Designing the constructions of plywoods (except for one model) (3) Providing the early performance indices for performa…

ttgearlab.com

 

[turbozed]

I don't think there'd be that much of a difference between the Fextra, Swat Power, and Xiom Offensive S. All 3 are relatively similar composition, thickness, and hardness (all around 1300-1350hz range in frequency). Not sure about the Szocs.

You might want to consider dropping down to an ALL+ or changing your rubber to something slower.

 

[Celebration]

Only the normal swat. Not swat power.
What all+ you can recommend?

 

[Scarfed Garchomp]

Swat Power is a different blade than Vanilla Swat. Vanilla Swat is thin like a 5 ply blade, sub-6mm overall thickness should make it slower and more flexible than the thicker Szocs and Fextra. I have had a pretty light Swat at 79g, it felt similar to a more solid feeling Stiga Allround Evolution rather than my Offensive S and Stratus Powerwood blades, which were a step up in terms of stiffness and offered a more solid feeling. My Swat I would place around all+/low off- speed, where the Off S and SPW I would put into mid to high off- territory.

 

[timdm]

I agree that, if fextra is too quick, you won't be better off with BSS or victas swat.
Go look for a 5ply all/all+ blade, I'm thinking a good old allround classic for example.

 

[Celebration]

So normal swat is slower or equal as the others ??

 

[vvk1]

So normal swat is slower or equal as the others ??

Speed: Swat < Offensive S < BSS