This user has no status.
This user has no status.
???? he's a better player than me. why try using my forehand more?? why don't you show me a video of you using your lesser quality stroke against a player that's better than you instead of doing the ones that give you a better chance. and when you ask me to try and beat him by more.... That's the most I've ever beaten him by. whether it be his lack of movement or whatever, that was the best scores I've had on him.
Hey man, please calm down. I'm trying to give constructive advice
I can understand your excitement when you beat hard a guy that you don't beat easily (or lose) usually. Everybody would be. Hell, i sometimes get excited because i lose, but i get one SET from someone !
When i said I want to use your FH more, its not at all an advice about the way to beat him. Its just because we don't see much of it during the game (the main reason being him playing to your BH) and that I'd like to see that aspect of your game and see you improving there. Wouldn't you like to be as good on the FH than on the BH ? Or do you believe your FH is already as good or better than your BH ??
Is he a better player than you ? Not this day. The general form of his strokes is more advanced than yours, but he wasn't moving, made easy mistakes, and kept playing in your BH. Maybe he was practising something, thinking about his date after the match or whatever...because mentally and tactically he wasn't good at all...
You have your strengths, and if he doesn't play more seriously next time, and gives always 3-4 free points per set, I would always bet on you.
I know you get coaching but my questions to you are as follows:
1. How old were you when you started playing?
2. How many older players have you extensively coached?
you're right his form is better and he's not moving. I've talked about this with him, he says he hasn't done footwork drills in more than 5 years.
to answer your question, on if I'd like my forehand to be ask good as my backhand, the answer is actually no. I hate speed. that's part of the reason I started playing long pips when I do a forehand it will generally be a block or a SLOW loop, because I'd prefer to be able to have time to get ready for the next stroke comfortably.
my backhand ends where it does because it's a short stroke, able to get ready for the next one quickly. I didn't post for critique purposes as much as to show my progress and so that when I give advice, the receiver of my advice understands my level of play.
Si-hing,
HARDCORE!!
Home is HK?
Safe sojourns!
Hey man, i live in Japan, and there is a tradition to respect the older and the more ancient. I know you've been contributing a lot to this community here and I certainly don't want to be the guy coming from nowhere and putting a mess here.
OK.
1. I am 44, i played at little bit at school but i played seriously only from 15 , 1 year at my local club only and doing junior competitions. Then from 21 to 28 I played in a club doing competitions as well. I wasn't specially gifted but i played a lot back then and managed to improve 100 points a year roughly to reach 1350 points (French system), so its like maybe 2000-2100 US ? from the conversion tables i see here and there.
Then i moved to Japan, i didn't play competitions and trained in good conditions for a long time so i think my level dropped something like 250 points for many years. I resumed training more seriously in London in 2012 taking private lessons, to get some consistency back, and from 2013 i train much more, including 1:1 weekly lessons with excellent professional coaches. Younger, i would just serve long and try to kill the ball immediately. i was very good at it, i wasn't able to do a proper BH topspin, in matches i would just push or block passively with it. But i was very quick on my legs so i tried to take everything with FH. Now my technique i think has improved a lot, but of course I'm much slower, although i think i'm still relatively fit for my age. No big belly yet... Overall i think i'm becoming a better player than back then just now.
Apart from playing with my coaches, there are a lot of people with my club, so i knock the ball regularly with players of all style ranging from beginners to around my level, to 500 points better to professional players...
2. How many players have i coached ? absolutely 0. Maybe i should have introduced myself first and said so ? So if someone wants to dismiss what i write cause i'm not a pro coach, yes you can absolutely. I mean, this is a free forum, i don't think there are only coaches contributing, and if someone posts a video here, he can expect to have a feedback from any random internet guy. My level is only intermediate and I wouldn't feel comfortable giving advice to players 500 points above, or even 300 points, but I don't think this is the case here. Also, the kind of advice i've gave is just repeating selected pieces that my own coaches are telling me. I am not trying to make something by myself... As i see things that i see myself doing, (like the upper body thing for Shuki) i think its worth mentioning.
I wouldn't also give any advice to any Penholder, or pips player, I don't know at all how to use those rubbers...
On the French forum luckily if you post a video, many good players give you feedback, there are even people who are top 1000 French players, so maybe that would be US top 100 ? that give regularly free advice. But free advice on this forum means NL. Just trying to contribute as well...If even 20% of what i write isn't BS and you can identify which it is, isn't is worth publishing ???? Apart from that, there are some sites where pro coaches will evaluate your videos for a fee...
Very funny. (..)
Only asking because coaching to some degree involves getting to understand the student. The more varied the advice from better players on this site, the better. Your voice is very valuable. So hearing your history helps Shuki understand where you are coming from better as well.
There is also an experience of people volunteering to get good at the game that is very important to relate to. I think spending some time trying to understand what Shuki is trying to do with his game will reward you, even if you don't agree with it. Even compared to the last videos that Shuki shared, the changes are interesting. Shuki is playing much more behind his serve than I remember.
Yup! Thanks!
Haha, today's flight was possibly the worst I ever had... since the flight was at 1am, I was tired already before boarding the plane, then there is the usual delay. I overestimated myself to being able to watch movies, so I began watching Jason Bourne. Half way through that, I decided I cant go on as my eyes just won't open anymore. Had a cup noodle on the plane. Not long later, 1st vomit. Then 2nd vomit. Then 3rd and then 4th. Until I knew there is nothing left in my stomach as I tried really hard to vomit but nothing more came out... I did not think clearly, and did not realise my problem then was dehydration apart from electrolyte imbalance. Got off the plane at SG for transit, still really dizzy, and feel nauseous as soon as I eat or drink anything. On my next flight which goes to HK, I then went straight for sleep. This time the result was much better, even though I did not finish a single movie, I did not have to vomit.
Now I am at home. Going to call up some local friends and try arrange a hit with them.
And this weather... meant to be winter, but feels like summer..
I have an extensive experience of trying to get better of that game and failing to do so very much... LOL
I'm sure Shuki is already getting coaching. He's not playing randomly at all, and he wouldn't have got that good all by himself
decided to record me and my teammate warming up/messing around yesterday. I feel this is something I have to start doing more, it feels strange to watch myself play but could be so useful. Hopefully I can get him to record some actual games with me next season.
Good fun to try new things and watch it back too, nice little around the net by him at the end![]()
I'm a little older here and I didn't know either!Hello Richie:
I'm new here, so I didn't know which was you until the end ... LOL at me
Nice shot by your partner!
Thank you for sharing your video with us!!
~osph
Ah, yes, he does. And I find that the experience of your failures is probably the most valuable thing that you can give people - how you tried to do something and it just didn't work, and how you think you solved it. Technical advice is common, connecting to people to give that advice not so much. But when people realize that you were where they were and experiencing similar problems and eventually solved them somehow, the problem tends to be less frightening.
I personally like Shuki's forehand (it's a backhand player's forehand) and his ability to play points like this one:
youtu.be/1qiEd_RA2EM?t=511
Could he play harder and more powerful forehands? Maybe. As you have pointed out, getting lower and using more direct technique could result in a higher quality game. But Shuki has pointed out that currently, high arc forehands with consistency fit his rally game better than faster ones. Could change tomorrow, and then maybe he will think about staying lower. But even if not, people with worse forehands have played better table tennis. My concern with Shuki's game has been that aspects of his grip limit the amount of spin he can generate. But whether I am right or wrong, he has navigated that as best he can. Will be interesting to see where it goes.
I personally am not a fan of the serves, but it takes a certain kind of player to punish those repeatedly to make him use a different strategy and he is playing a friend.
Ahh, today was a good day.
Yesterday I said there are no stable blockers around here, but I lied. I forgot one player who doesn't play too much because of a recent minor injury. However he is getting better and playing more because he is basically healed. I played some matches with him and a chopper. I won most of them, but they were close. It's very refreshing to play against someone who knows how to block low and move the ball around. I think he is a better blocker than me to be honest. Much better.
The chopper wasn't an issue, and I could loop his chop even 5 times in a row and move him in and out with pushes and loops, but that's just because his overall level is somewhat lower. I can get his backspin over the net with just a good blade angle, so it's not very heavy at all. However I am proud that I could move to the ball and see the bounce well enough to slow loop it consistently even if the ball I produced is not a very quality ball.
After, I tried some NL-inspired straight arm looping on self hit balls, because I remembered his comments about lack of whip. I'd never tried to *really* let my arm go all the way back and whip forward, so I didn't know what to expect. I tried to copy the rhythm, and I hit it first try.
I actually had more success this way to get pace and spin than any other way I'd tried to now, which is funny because I thought I would just keep missing. However the timing feels very difficult to adapt to a real ball, and I can feel my body resisting the acceleration. I have newfound respect for NL's straight arm loop.
Normally my self hit topspin shots impact the wall opposite of me, come back some then spin back to the wall somewhat slowly. Straight arm shots like this will impact the wall, barely come back half a meter, spin to the wall, then rebound AGAIN a small distance and spin once more to the wall. Wow.
My rubber is worn and not a modern looping rubber, and I can actually feel the potential that I'm not using, so I really can't imagine what you can do with perfect mechanics and good equipment.
I've seen this kind of behavior from the ball on the ground even to a higher degree when watching top level pros training, but they aren't doing half as big strokes, and they're pretty soft compared to what they can do, so it's pretty incredible.