Different (fiber) blade philosophies

says Fighting the EJ bug again...
says Fighting the EJ bug again...
Member
Mar 2025
458
695
2,996
Read 1 reviews
Fextra is interesting in that it doesn't really conform to the sort of rule you've laid out, @Tyce. It's solid enough to play harder Chinese rubbers, and yet it also plays well with Euro rubbers. I recently bought one (89g) and glued Joola Rhyzen Fire & Ice to it (47° and 42° respective Euro-style rubbers) and it plays very naturally. It feels not terribly different from my inner-carbon Yinhe Pro 05, which likewise I play with Euro rubbers but is "designed" for Chinese provincial players. Even my coach was impressed with the combination.

My sense is that there are probably some blades that lean more in one direction or the other as far as rubber pairings, but it's probably not black-and-white and in the end it's down to personal feeling anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tyce
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,131
1,936
6,312
Read 2 reviews
Contact time/dwell tends to be exaggerated - we're talking 1-2ms. It's also unlikely that blade flex + restitution occurs within that contact window to contribute to any sort of catapult (throw is different). A blade that flexes too easily is actually more lossy and would be slower.

I think these things primarily change what you feel, but what you feel doesn't change the shot as you're making it, it just calibrates your brain for the future.
Experimental results I've seen suggest under 1ms for fairly low speed impacts. Maybe it's higher in higher speed impacts that are really tangential. Either way might as well be instant. You only see the compression in ultra high speed footage slowed down thousands of times.

I'm gonna get flamed to hell and back but it's 99% the after-effect of the shot and what you feel in the hand from the handle pitching and rolling and vibrating, and nothing to do with the shot itself other than the coefficient of restitution and maybe throw angle if the blade face does deflect enough.
 
Looping with H3 requires more brushing and less punching. Longer arc with higher speed, all body in motion.

More flex = more contact time = easy looping.
Also, more flex = higher throw = easy looping with low throw rubbers.
I never understood the idea of Chinese rubbers on a flexible 5ply
Yeah, I've done that, I highly recommend nobody does this
In general, flexible 5ply is for beginers. For someone advanced, the same 5ply can be a limitation.

Flexible 5-ply + Chinese rubber is an incredible combination and it has great synergy with a certain type of playing style, even at the professional level. Ma Lin and Xu Xin both used this setup -- Ma Lin EO + Skyline 2 -- for example. It works well for a playstyle with a very controlled spinny short game, plus having the strength to hit powerful bomba shots when given the opportunity.

A flexy blade removes power from looping, up to a certain point. Deforming the shape of the blade requires energy, and that energy gets subtracted from your loop and the incoming energy of the ball. But if you hit hard enough, the blade will reach its maximum flex and start to act like a spring, accumulating potential energy and propelling the ball out as you hit. This lets players use the flex to absorb energy if they play softly, convert incoming energy into rotational energy, and also use the flex as a spring for extra power when hitting hard.

Ma Lin Extra Offensive + Skyline 2 is such an incredible equipment combination, especially for penholders. Lets you play incredible spins, chop blocks, and drop shots while also retaining power for devastating flicks and power loops.
 
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,131
1,936
6,312
Read 2 reviews
Flexible 5ply + Chinese hard sponge is a great combo, but you will lose out on potential speed and spin at the higher impact forces compared to a blade that is stiffer. I know I just get objectively higher shot quality with HL5 and H3 than something like an allround blade + H3.

The reason I'd still maybe want to use an allround blade at my low play level is because it has relatively more hysteresis and damping which might be a desirable characteristic. I think at the higher levels it just doesn't keep up speed wise and everyone has good enough control to mostly offset the negatives.
 
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,131
1,936
6,312
Read 2 reviews
Aren't the same rubber, B2 have more speed & less spin than H3.
I wouldn't say so, the actual performance is very different. In my hands, H3 is faster almost always. Much spinnier too. B2 should be faster when hitting very flat, maybe due to pimple structure, maybe due to its less progressive sponge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mihalichtheone
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,131
1,936
6,312
Read 2 reviews
I was speaking about Provincial version with BS for both rubbers.
B2 Provincial is far behind H3 Commercial in performance and consistency. Also much worse topsheet gluing.

B2 National Super Select is about as consistent as H3 Provincial although the playing quality is much lower still.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mihalichtheone
says what [IMG]
says what [IMG]
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Feb 2016
3,131
1,936
6,312
Read 2 reviews
I don't agree, B2 provincial is way better than H3 commercial, try both without booster and let's see how performs both rubbers.
Those are the only forehand rubbers I've seriously used in the past half a year or so. I wouldn't recommend using either unboosted, especially B2 becomes much more compliant with just one layer of Seamoon. The topsheet is not very flexible compared to H3.

B2 does have an advantage though in how very spinny brush loops appear low quality to the opponent, H3 for some reason, maybe due to a higher spin level, looks more "viscous" and the sound is different so it's an easier tell. B2 doesn't produce the same quality, but it's more deceptive.

If you're not able to hit through the H3 sponge then B2 may be better quality though, I don't know for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mihalichtheone
This user has no status.
Funny thing. I went from that 5ply, to a Clipper and now to a soft inner with Innerforce Layer ALC. A hinoki topped 3+2 also pairs nicely with Chinese.
Honestly I don't like the Innerforce ALC with Hurricane and Clipper just had wrong shapes and sizes that didn't feel comfortable. I can see the potential though as it kind of worked when I had Rxton 3 Pro on it.
Sanwei Fextra does pair well with H3 and also Mercury 2. I could try to fit grip tape to beef up the flat handle a bit.

I think Innerforce Layer ALC is a bit weird. It does kinda work with most rubbers, even H3N if I'm fair, but there's always something off. It just doesn't behave like I expect it to. Not flexible enough to get high dwell on opening up, and not stiff enough to be stable on a compact drive over the table. It tries to be everything but ends up being only capable of handling rubber well that is trying the same thing.
Funny enough I have a similar feeling with my Innerforce Layer ALC. It was an expensive blade so I'll work my technique around the blade's feel. TTgearlab makes a comment is consistent with your observation.


"When compared with other inner ALC blades, ‘InnerForce Layer ALC’ is expected to be more suitable for all-round play."
It's an all-around blade, which can be both good and bad depending on what you want.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Mar 2022
146
87
289
I don't really understand this. With a more flexible blade, you will need to put in more power to deflect the sponge a given amount. How does it make it easier to engage?
Maybe its compensating. But generally I've thought Chinese rubber needs harder blade. Thinking of the old dhs maple blades and pf4 etc
 
Top