Yay! I am a looper now, so what next?

says Making a beautiful shot is most important; winning is...
says Making a beautiful shot is most important; winning is...
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Mar 2021
4,848
5,737
12,094
First off, thank you Sensei Tom aka @TableTennisTom for responding. I am a sub and follower of your channel.

Alternatively, you build your game around your flat hit. You do serves which set up a flat hit. You develop tactics which force your opponent to pop the ball up, and then flat hit. At the amateur level, there are very good players who play a flatter game. It is possible.
I have using this tactic for sometime. It works! But no so when faced with better player because it is not easy to get those low hanging fruits anymore. That is why I am trying to transition into a looper.

To change this mindset is incredibly challenging. So you have a couple of options. If you travel down the topspin route, then you have to develop the skill of being able to hit 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7+ topspins in a row. You will undoubtedly end up a better player, but it will take time and a lot of training.
Yes! You are right, it has to do with mindset. Previously, being a flat hitter, I have high expectation that the ball will not come back but now they come back and many times I got into the deer in the headlights moments because the ball comes back. I need to mentally change this.
 
Last edited:
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Moderator
Oct 2014
19,979
26,544
70,909
Read 17 reviews
Once upon a time, comment about Gozo from TTD forum members:
1. Gozo you have no spin!
2. Gozo, you only flat hit ball, no spin! TT is all about spin!
3. Gozo, go learn to spin the ball!

With those comment in mind, I learned how to be a looper. I paid good money to some local coach to learn how to loop. I look up to Aruna Q. as my idol, as my go-to role model to be a looper.

Now I am looping the ball. Happy me right? No, not quiet. The story does not end here.

4. Each time I loop to open up, some wise guy will either block back fast to two wings, making life difficult for lil'poor Gozo.
5. Or some wise guy will quick drive back to me and I suffer deer in the headlight syndrome.
6. It appears to me, looping ball, those that come with a curve, are more easily blocked compared to a straight smash, that is to say, ball that travel in a straight line.
7. So, now I am asking, why bother with looping. Why is looping so hyped in the first place.
8. Or am I doing something wrong?
1. Where is the video of you looping consistently?
2. There are levels to everything and very few people hit their best level when they start doing something.

======
Story Time:

Once upon a time, there was a guy who liked to drive the ball. And his drive was good. And he was getting better. Or so he thought.

One day, he went to a tournament with his coach and the coach's students. The other students won their matches and played in a final against each other, and he lost to a guy who limped and pushed the ball 0-11 in the 3rd game. He was confused as to why everyone was getting better and he was not.

On the way back from the tournament, he lamented to his coach about his stagnation. And the coach told him that the other students would tell him what he was doing wrong. And that he should listen carefully, as the students know how they play him and win points. The guy paused and listened.

"You don't spin the ball."
"Come on, I do spin the ball!"
"Not really..."

So with that, the guy realized that may he had to change the way he played a little. He worked with his coach for the next few months on spinning the ball. He looped to pips, did speed looping drills, all with the goal of enhancing the usage of his wrist to add rotation to the ball.

He played a tournament. And he competed well against players he could not pressure in the past. And he could see that the spin helped him attack more balls that he couldn't attack before, and that it helped him stay consistent when out of position.

The crowning moment for him was when he played the man who he had lost 0-11 to in the third again. And in the times before Adam Bobrow made it a meme, the man stopped the match while he was down and said "What Happened???" He could not understand how the guy who he beat easily with pushes and chops and pick hits was now looping his pushes on both forehand and backhand and causing him to block balls off the table and chop balls into the sky.

Our hero: I just learned to spin the ball and I liked it and got better at it.
The opponent: Keep doing it, the change is amazing.

And our guy kept doing it. And he got so good doing it that even when other people say he cannot do this or that, the one thing they marvel at is how much spin he puts on the ball because they can feel it. He adapted this spin to his serving, and gets pips players to repeatedly put his serve into the net. He is notorious for attacking the backspin ball at his level on both sides, which makes him tough to play as people know that a push is never safe...


THE END
======

Gozo, you can practice smashing the topspin ball if you still want to go that route. But the key with learning how to spin is that it gives you more options. There are still lots of ideas you have not tapped into which depending on how you are coached you may or may not be shown. Mastering spin creation is the most straightforward way to raise your playing level. Because once you have it, you can reduce it. And it enables you to make shots like this (yes, this is my doing my scrubplayer humblebrag), the most critical is having more options for attacking half long and short serves:


So you only just began a journey, don't take it as if just acquiring the ability is the end of the road. In fact, your now goal should be to get your spin to a level where most players who are not trained struggle to block your balls. Good luck!
 
says Making a beautiful shot is most important; winning is...
says Making a beautiful shot is most important; winning is...
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Mar 2021
4,848
5,737
12,094
Grumble grumble grumble.... walking towards my store-room to dust off my camera tripod. Looks like I have to take some video and do editing. Troublesome! (j/kiddin )

I recall Carl once commented at me with something like this, " How do you know there is no spin? Look at your ball when you hit the ground or the net, if the ball is still spinning, then you are spinning the ball and if it isn't then you aren't "

It was based on this, I know I am spinning the ball. But anyway, I will take video at some opportune time to showcase my new me. It has been a while since I took video of my game... few months I believe so.
 
says Spin and more spin.
says Spin and more spin.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Moderator
Dec 2010
16,640
18,535
56,964
Read 11 reviews
Grumble grumble grumble.... walking towards my store-room to dust off my camera tripod. Looks like I have to take some video and do editing. Troublesome! (j/kiddin )

I recall Carl once commented at me with something like this, " How do you know there is no spin? Look at your ball when you hit the ground or the net, if the ball is still spinning, then you are spinning the ball and if it isn't then you aren't "

It was based on this, I know I am spinning the ball. But anyway, I will take video at some opportune time to showcase my new me. It has been a while since I took video of my game... few months I believe so.

I think you may have missed some of the quote: high levels of spin, the ball should be fizzing with spin when it hits the net; when it hits the ground it should shoot across the room faster than it was going in the air.

Can you show us a serve that bounces back to the net, or even better, back OVER the net to your side?

If you can't get your backspin serves to jump back to the net with with a decent amount of speed from the backspin, the spin you are talking about is not the spin I am talking about. Not the spin NextLevel is talking about. And I can promise you, NextLevel's shots feel like a brick is hitting your racket because of how much spin is on them despite the speed. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: NextLevel
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Jan 2021
3,922
2,876
8,104
Read 1 reviews
Grumble grumble grumble.... walking towards my store-room to dust off my camera tripod. Looks like I have to take some video and do editing. Troublesome! (j/kiddin )

I recall Carl once commented at me with something like this, " How do you know there is no spin? Look at your ball when you hit the ground or the net, if the ball is still spinning, then you are spinning the ball and if it isn't then you aren't "

It was based on this, I know I am spinning the ball. But anyway, I will take video at some opportune time to showcase my new me. It has been a while since I took video of my game... few months I believe so.
You feel when you hit a spinny shot, you see it on the trajectory and on the table bounce. In the beginning it’s not gonna be much spin, but keep it up and it will get much better.

My former coach always told me.”More spin Lazer…you need more spin”… My shots are getting more and more spinny but not enough… Wonder if it is ever enough 🙃

Cheers
L-zr
 
Last edited:
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Jan 2024
81
120
209
Once upon a time, comment about Gozo from TTD forum members:
1. Gozo you have no spin!
2. Gozo, you only flat hit ball, no spin! TT is all about spin!
3. Gozo, go learn to spin the ball!

With those comment in mind, I learned how to be a looper. I paid good money to some local coach to learn how to loop. I look up to Aruna Q. as my idol, as my go-to role model to be a looper.

Now I am looping the ball. Happy me right? No, not quiet. The story does not end here.

4. Each time I loop to open up, some wise guy will either block back fast to two wings, making life difficult for lil'poor Gozo.
5. Or some wise guy will quick drive back to me and I suffer deer in the headlight syndrome.
6. It appears to me, looping ball, those that come with a curve, are more easily blocked compared to a straight smash, that is to say, ball that travel in a straight line.
7. So, now I am asking, why bother with looping. Why is looping so hyped in the first place.
8. Or am I doing something wrong?
8. Yes. I was there too for many years. Using these techniques I was lucky to be a bad div 1 player.

The loop that you learn of in forums and youtube tutorials is outdated, or perhaps not optimal is a better description - I will tell you why in a later paragraph.

In my opinion, you should learn what they call the 'mini loop' on this forum, right off the bounce. That way, you get a quick attack, and can recover in time for the next one. Your opponent will likely back off the table, which will then give you time to do bigger loops if you wish to. This is stereo-typically known as the 'woman's game', but it is far superior to the men's game for most people (most people can't generate enough power to justify the large strokes). For the mini-loop, the closer you do it to the bounce, the easier it will be to lift underspin. This is a challenge, as most people don't judge the ball early enough to be in position to get it early - it takes a lot of practice and a very stable technique. Don't expect to master it without a lot of effort and time.

I remember when I was playing those big spinny loops many years ago, I came across a player that wouldn't be affected by my heavy spin. He would just direct the ball to the open court. So he would push, I would loop like a madman, and he just places the ball out of reach - point over. There was nothing I could do, I couldn't recover in time. It was my only weapon and this player rendered it useless. Any good player will do the same to anyone with excessive movements close to the table.

If you really still want to play those bigger loops, you need to ensure you have a very small weight transfer. If your hip movement is too big, you can't recover. You should be using fingers and wrist when close to the table to generate spin and power. Only increase hips when you are away from the table and need more power. This way you at least give yourself time to recover for the next shot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brs
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Apr 2023
1,977
1,940
8,461
This is a long post and I have said a few of these things before.

Do you have a coach who is explaining to you how he is building your loop along the way?

I learned looping in the 38mm ball era. My Chinese coach started me learning how to loop no spin ball, on the way own, standing a bit further away from the table. Using this method, he was trying to get me to feel what it is like to brush a ball properly and "lift" it over to the other side of the table with a good arc.

Once that was done, he had me loop backspin ball coming at me, also on the way down, and lift it with slow spinny loops.

The last piece of the puzzle was him having me learn how to loop backspin, no spin and topspin at the top of the bounce. That is the loop kill or loop drive I am referring to. When the final piece of the puzzle fell into place, I had already learned how to brush properly by then.

Along the way, here is also the sequence he taught me: 1) use elbow/forearm to generate spin and once I perfected that, he added 2) waist movement/hip rotation and then 3) pushing off the floor with my legs. Those all happened in the first two phases: spin the ball with lots and lots of spin while the ball is on the way down.

During the second phase (looping underspin ball on its way down), he also asked me to "explode" or "accelerate" into the ball, regardless of how much backspin is on the ball. I remember this phase of the training very well because he basically asked me to rebuild my topspin loop at that point.

The more backspin is on the ball, the faster you need to explode with your body to lift the ball properly. Whenever a player learning how to loop backspin, the most common reason for the ball to fall into the net is that there is no to little "explosion" or "acceleration." It is like, you need to whip your whole body into the shot. The more backspin is there on the ball, the more you need to "whip" your body. In this case, timing is crucial. Basically you have to time the ball correctly, relax your body completely. When the ball comes to you (because you timed it properly), you immediately explode (from a relaxed position) and whip your whole body into the ball and finish with a follow through. the follow through should end where you want to guide the ball to. In other words, the follow through should end to your left if you are aiming for the opponent's forehand. The follow through should end to the right side of your head if you are aiming for opponent's backhand, assuming the opponent is right handed.

The problem with the last phase of building my loop was that I was confused. Up to that point, I could lift any heavy backspin balls by lightly brushing the ball and I won a lot of points in practice matches with other juniors back then (it was 38mm celluloid ball after all). So, literally one day at our session, he basically told me to stop doing that! Instead, in all of our subsequent multiball sessions, he gave me heavier and heavier backspin balls and asked me to loop or whip through ball. I was confused because wouldn't that mean the ball would hit the net and bounce back to my end of the table? He simply said, trust me and just do it! Don't ask too many questions!

Lots and lots of multi-ball sessions later, I finally got what he was referring to. It does not matter how much backspin is on the ball, just as long as you loop drive at the top of the bounce with even faster acceleration, you can loop drive/loop kill any ball (mind you, up to that point, I was taught to loop the ball on the way down. now he wanted me to loop the ball on the top of the bounce? That in itself took some time for me to adjust because timing was different and the height of the ball was different).

In the final phase (looping underspin, topspin or no spin at the top of the bounce), he also asked me to add shoulder movement into my loop and push off the ground even harder. Pushing off the ground was easy (he already taught me that in phase 1 and 2 of the training). But adding shoulder movement? I found that to be hard. Up to that point, it was already difficult enough to time the ball correctly, move my feet to where the ball should be and engage my elbow/forearm, waist/hip and my legs all the same time, while trying to be relaxed and then explode through the ball. To add shoulder movement really set me back for a few months until it became natural.

Wrist movement. He did not teach me any of that because when you are building your forehand loop, if you move your wrist by the slightest angle, your ball will fly all over the place. So he asked to lock my wrist and move my elbow, shoulder, hip and legs in one synchronous motion. I added wrist later on on my own after I got comfortable with looping.

Fang Bao has very very good YouTube videos. However, I don't think they are useful for beginners and intermediate players. The videos I have watched, it is just a bunch of experts who started playing when they were 4 or 5 year old displaying what a perfect loop looks like. It is totally useless for adult beginners. You are not going to get to a perfect loop from the get-go. You have to build the loop step by step.

Of note, every coach has a different idea on how to build a loop for your OVER TIME. It is not going to happen in 1 day or 2 weeks or even 2 months. To perfect loops, it takes years!

As for slow spinny loop, that's where I use the tacky top sheet to lift the ball. As for fast, spinny loop at the top of the bounce, I do the full motion and engage both the top sheet and the sponge.

Going back to the topic of looping a heavy backspin ball into the net. The number 1 reason again is, not enough acceleration or explosion. But in order to be able to accelerate and explode properly you need to 1) move your feet into the right place at the table, 2) account for the height of the ball (every ball coming at you will vary in heights) and 3) be TOTALLY relaxed. If you are not relaxed completely, you cannot accelerate or explode because you are already tight. Not being relaxed totally prior to initiating the looping motion seems to be the biggest problem for adult beginners because they are "tight" and they are "scared" and they are "nervous." You have to get all those fears out of your head if you want to loop with quality. You need to be completely relaxed (head included; I am semi joking or semi serious. If your head/brain is not relaxed, then your whole body is not relaxed and you are going to generate really bad loops with low quality).

I started playing ping pong seriously with a coach when I was 13. So I could see things from both a 5 or 6 year old perspective v.s. an adult beginner perspective. But that's why Fang Bo or ZJK is probably terrible at teaching adult beginners because to them, once they picked up the paddle at the age of 5 or 6, all the above were natural and instinctive for them at that age. To teach adult beginners, you need a whole set of different strategy/lesson plans. You need to build your loop over time and have the patience to get to the end.

Of note, maybe the way my coach taught me is out of date in the 40mm plastic ball era. The coaches at the club I am playing at emphasize looping on the top of the bounce or slightly below the top of the bounce. I personally don't get that. Maybe they are trying to give adult beginners confidence? I still believe that loop should be taught in the beginning with the ball on the way down because you need to learn to brush the ball and "lift" the ball over to the other side of the table. If you teach adult beginners to loop at the top of the bounce, you are basically teaching them to smash and hit the ball because that feels natural to them (hey, the ball is high, then just smack the heck out of the ball).

In other words, the answer to your question is that, your loop has not been built yet and you are already asking too many questions. When you build your loop over time, you have to trust your coach and trust the process. If you want to win at the table today with your newly developed loops, then you have lost already because you are tight, standing there. How can you loop properly when you are already tight?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saiph and Wrighty67
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Oct 2023
84
36
171
This is a long post and I have said a few of these things before.

Do you have a coach who is explaining to you how he is building your loop along the way?

I learned looping in the 38mm ball era. My Chinese coach started me learning how to loop no spin ball, on the way own, standing a bit further away from the table. Using this method, he was trying to get me to feel what it is like to brush a ball properly and "lift" it over to the other side of the table with a good arc.

Once that was done, he had me loop backspin ball coming at me, also on the way down, and lift it with slow spinny loops.

The last piece of the puzzle was him having me learn how to loop backspin, no spin and topspin at the top of the bounce. That is the loop kill or loop drive I am referring to. When the final piece of the puzzle fell into place, I had already learned how to brush properly by then.

Along the way, here is also the sequence he taught me: 1) use elbow/forearm to generate spin and once I perfected that, he added 2) waist movement/hip rotation and then 3) pushing off the floor with my legs. Those all happened in the first two phases: spin the ball with lots and lots of spin while the ball is on the way down.

During the second phase (looping underspin ball on its way down), he also asked me to "explode" or "accelerate" into the ball, regardless of how much backspin is on the ball. I remember this phase of the training very well because he basically asked me to rebuild my topspin loop at that point.

The more backspin is on the ball, the faster you need to explode with your body to lift the ball properly. Whenever a player learning how to loop backspin, the most common reason for the ball to fall into the net is that there is no to little "explosion" or "acceleration." It is like, you need to whip your whole body into the shot. The more backspin is there on the ball, the more you need to "whip" your body. In this case, timing is crucial. Basically you have to time the ball correctly, relax your body completely. When the ball comes to you (because you timed it properly), you immediately explode (from a relaxed position) and whip your whole body into the ball and finish with a follow through. the follow through should end where you want to guide the ball to. In other words, the follow through should end to your left if you are aiming for the opponent's forehand. The follow through should end to the right side of your head if you are aiming for opponent's backhand, assuming the opponent is right handed.

The problem with the last phase of building my loop was that I was confused. Up to that point, I could lift any heavy backspin balls by lightly brushing the ball and I won a lot of points in practice matches with other juniors back then (it was 38mm celluloid ball after all). So, literally one day at our session, he basically told me to stop doing that! Instead, in all of our subsequent multiball sessions, he gave me heavier and heavier backspin balls and asked me to loop or whip through ball. I was confused because wouldn't that mean the ball would hit the net and bounce back to my end of the table? He simply said, trust me and just do it! Don't ask too many questions!

Lots and lots of multi-ball sessions later, I finally got what he was referring to. It does not matter how much backspin is on the ball, just as long as you loop drive at the top of the bounce with even faster acceleration, you can loop drive/loop kill any ball (mind you, up to that point, I was taught to loop the ball on the way down. now he wanted me to loop the ball on the top of the bounce? That in itself took some time for me to adjust because timing was different and the height of the ball was different).

In the final phase (looping underspin, topspin or no spin at the top of the bounce), he also asked me to add shoulder movement into my loop and push off the ground even harder. Pushing off the ground was easy (he already taught me that in phase 1 and 2 of the training). But adding shoulder movement? I found that to be hard. Up to that point, it was already difficult enough to time the ball correctly, move my feet to where the ball should be and engage my elbow/forearm, waist/hip and my legs all the same time, while trying to be relaxed and then explode through the ball. To add shoulder movement really set me back for a few months until it became natural.

Wrist movement. He did not teach me any of that because when you are building your forehand loop, if you move your wrist by the slightest angle, your ball will fly all over the place. So he asked to lock my wrist and move my elbow, shoulder, hip and legs in one synchronous motion. I added wrist later on on my own after I got comfortable with looping.

Fang Bao has very very good YouTube videos. However, I don't think they are useful for beginners and intermediate players. The videos I have watched, it is just a bunch of experts who started playing when they were 4 or 5 year old displaying what a perfect loop looks like. It is totally useless for adult beginners. You are not going to get to a perfect loop from the get-go. You have to build the loop step by step.

Of note, every coach has a different idea on how to build a loop for your OVER TIME. It is not going to happen in 1 day or 2 weeks or even 2 months. To perfect loops, it takes years!

As for slow spinny loop, that's where I use the tacky top sheet to lift the ball. As for fast, spinny loop at the top of the bounce, I do the full motion and engage both the top sheet and the sponge.

Going back to the topic of looping a heavy backspin ball into the net. The number 1 reason again is, not enough acceleration or explosion. But in order to be able to accelerate and explode properly you need to 1) move your feet into the right place at the table, 2) account for the height of the ball (every ball coming at you will vary in heights) and 3) be TOTALLY relaxed. If you are not relaxed completely, you cannot accelerate or explode because you are already tight. Not being relaxed totally prior to initiating the looping motion seems to be the biggest problem for adult beginners because they are "tight" and they are "scared" and they are "nervous." You have to get all those fears out of your head if you want to loop with quality. You need to be completely relaxed (head included; I am semi joking or semi serious. If your head/brain is not relaxed, then your whole body is not relaxed and you are going to generate really bad loops with low quality).

I started playing ping pong seriously with a coach when I was 13. So I could see things from both a 5 or 6 year old perspective v.s. an adult beginner perspective. But that's why Fang Bo or ZJK is probably terrible at teaching adult beginners because to them, once they picked up the paddle at the age of 5 or 6, all the above were natural and instinctive for them at that age. To teach adult beginners, you need a whole set of different strategy/lesson plans. You need to build your loop over time and have the patience to get to the end.

Of note, maybe the way my coach taught me is out of date in the 40mm plastic ball era. The coaches at the club I am playing at emphasize looping on the top of the bounce or slightly below the top of the bounce. I personally don't get that. Maybe they are trying to give adult beginners confidence? I still believe that loop should be taught in the beginning with the ball on the way down because you need to learn to brush the ball and "lift" the ball over to the other side of the table. If you teach adult beginners to loop at the top of the bounce, you are basically teaching them to smash and hit the ball because that feels natural to them (hey, the ball is high, then just smack the heck out of the ball).

In other words, the answer to your question is that, your loop has not been built yet and you are already asking too many questions. When you build your loop over time, you have to trust your coach and trust the process. If you want to win at the table today with your newly developed loops, then you have lost already because you are tight, standing there. How can you loop properly when you are already tight?
Thank you very much for sharing this! Really a long post though.

My coach doesn't teach me this and I think building a foundation like this really comes a long way. I think I'll have to discuss some things with my coach the next time I'm training
 
  • Like
Reactions: JJ Ng
says Making a beautiful shot is most important; winning is...
says Making a beautiful shot is most important; winning is...
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Mar 2021
4,848
5,737
12,094
So today while playing I made a conscious effort to loop every ball, even blocked ball from my open ups that come back with topspin. I made conscious effort to avoid flat hitting but to close my angle of my racquet and to brush more.... loop drive to be precise.

I have mixed result. The good part is, if I am successful, the ball is so spinny, my opponent blocks either goes out of the table or goes into the net.

The bad part is, I do miss about 50% of the shots, but I guess this is just transitional mistake. As I practice more, the error should reduce.

I can see better that loop drive produces quality shops more that flat smash. It is not so easy to block a ball loaded with spin that is coming fast, i.e., a loop-drive.
 
Top