This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Well-Known Member
Moderator
Other than a few people who have extremely strong or personal reasons to be fans of and support the success of apecific players (maybe they want Odo or Nagasaki to qualify over Hayata because those are their favorite players), this is how most regular fans think. For some reason people think it is easy to be as consistent as Hayata has been in remaining at the top. Somehow lots of unnamed players not named Miwa Harimoto are supposedly doing it. And if Hayata falls from thr top, so be it, let her overall performance dictate that. Cherrypicking losses in finals, semi finals and quarter finals to top level opposition who will largely beat anyone they face at similar stages is somehow a strong argument in the minds of many but that is emotional thinking, not evidence-based logic. If this was about picking Miwa vs Hayata, there would be no debate. But when it becomes Hayata against anyone else, everyone begins to forget how well you have to play to get to a stage that the CNT even cares about you and when you do, they forget the resources.I support whoever makes the team whether or not that includes Hayata. But currently, she has the 2nd highest ranking in Japan and there's a high probability she will kick off 2027 in that 2nd position. That's the cold hard fact that you don't seem to accept. If Sato or Odo moves into the 2nd spot, I'm perfectly fine with that. It means they've worked hard to outrank Hayata. But beyond that, all of the Japanese women, obviously including Hina, need to up their game to compete with China.
I would be happy to replace Hayata if there were clearly better options. But at this point, people think options even if not clearly better is a brilliant argument. I don't think Mizutani ever beat Ma Long or Zhang Jike. But i could be wrong.