MX-P on FH, but what for BH? Need help to choose!

Rub

This user has no status.
Hi everyone!
After nearly a year playing with a Tibhar Evolution MX-P on my forehand and an FX-P on my backhand, I need to change my rubbers, but I have a question I’d like to ask you all. On my forehand, I don’t plan to change the MX-P, as I’m very comfortable with it and it’s perfect for my shots, but on my backhand I’m torn between several options. My backhand game is less attacking than my forehand; my shots are more controlled and I mainly use it for spinny flicks and loops, quick, well-placed shots and to set up a forehand winner. I also use it a lot for blocking. But I don’t usually finish the point with a backhand winner. I’ve been considering several rubbers:
- Evolution MX-P
- Evolution MX-S
- Evolution FX-S
- Glayzer/09c
- Or simply stick with the FX-P

I’d like to hear your thoughts on whether I should switch to any of these rubbers or others you might suggest, based on the description I’ve given and bearing in mind that I prioritise spin and control over excessive speed. I want them to be good-quality rubbers that aren’t too expensive, preferably from the Tibhar brand (as I’m very used to their style and I think they suit my game best). I know it’s very difficult to picture a player’s style of play without a video or something similar to go by, but any opinion is greatly appreciated.
 

Rub

This user has no status.
Out of all the rubbers you listed, there is nothing close to FX-P for keeping it on the table.

THAT is what you are trying to do on BH, right? Plus, you have spin attacking potential there too. Isn't that a goal on BH?
I want something a bit more aggressive, which still has spin and a bit of control. Sorry, it was my mistake – I accidentally posted it too early.
 

Rub

This user has no status.
Out of all the rubbers you listed, there is nothing close to FX-P for keeping it on the table.

THAT is what you are trying to do on BH, right? Plus, you have spin attacking potential there too. Isn't that a goal on BH?
As I have MX-P on my FH, I've tried it on by BH too, and it felt much better than I expected - I thought its hardness would be just too much for my BH shots, but it felt so comfortable and quite easy to control while kkeping spin. That's why I have so many doubts about what BH rubber to choose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Der_Echte
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Apr 2014
1,935
1,518
3,538
Read 3 reviews
For forehand consider trying MX-P 50 in the future.
Or don´t. Not only is its sponge harder but also different, which makes it considerably more difficult to play than just a harder sponge MX-P.
And EL-P has a stiffer topsheet than any other Evolution. They advertised it as something like the golden middle, but while FX-P and MX-P share the topsheet and only differ in sponge hardness, EL-P is something else. Can work though.
But if you already tried MX-P on your backhand and like it, you may have your answer anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rub
says Certified USATT Coach
says Certified USATT Coach
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Sep 2011
13,580
14,438
32,732
Read 27 reviews
As I have MX-P on my FH, I've tried it on by BH too, and it felt much better than I expected - I thought its hardness would be just too much for my BH shots, but it felt so comfortable and quite easy to control while kkeping spin. That's why I have so many doubts about what BH rubber to choose.
Of course, a player has to personally try out each rubber on same blade, or same rubber with each blade to get an idea of holistically things work.

If your BH impact for the majority of shots show MX-P is more consistent with enough quality, the result would speak for itself, give as much stuff a shot as you can.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rub
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Mar 2015
1,512
1,237
4,455
Read 3 reviews
EL-S can be very spinny, but it's controllable. It's easier to play on the BH than with MX-S, it's not as fast as the MX-P,
the topsheet is IMHO just straight up an upgrade over the EL-P. And it's more solid, less bouncy than the FX-P. Honestly, both the FX-P and the EL_S are excellent choices, but which one? I can't tell, it's up to personal preference. I would recommend trying out both of them if you can.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Apr 2014
1,935
1,518
3,538
Read 3 reviews
EL-S can be very spinny, but it's controllable.
Some would disagree because of its characteristics.
It is designed to make opening shots on downspin easy, then kinda shift into another gear when playing the next ball on the incoming block of the first.
It´s nothing one can´t adjust to, I never had any issue with this, but I read in forum posts that it´s not linear enough for some.
It is an excellent rubber for sure and got developed out of the playing characteristics of 45 degree FX-P/MX-P, which was a rubber labelled with both names according to which pro it was delivered to. Lebesson for example used a "hard" FX-P, others had "soft" MX-P. Some tweaking in the aforementioned style and out came EL-S.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Apr 2014
1,935
1,518
3,538
Read 3 reviews
What about its durability?
Like most hybrid rubbers, not exactly something to celebrate ;)

If you consider this rubber, keep in mind that even the soft FX version has a sponge way harder than your FX-P does. This alone shouldn´t be a big problem as you can play with MX-P on your backhand too, but the stickiness is a different thing.
I agree that MK is a very good rubber, but not sure it´s the right thing for you.
That said, you might want to take a look at Quantum X Pro, which is also available in a soft version.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jonol and Rub
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Apr 2014
1,935
1,518
3,538
Read 3 reviews
I'd just use softest of Evolution Series for reference for a bit
FX-P is already the softest, and the one that might be replaced.
Going from Evolution to older Aurus series doesn´t seem like a really good idea to me, although Aurus Soft is a rubber used by many.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jonol and Rub
says Won 2, lost 1 in club training today. Revenge for the...
says Won 2, lost 1 in club training today. Revenge for the...
Member
Jun 2018
126
106
298
FX-P is already the softest, and the one that might be replaced.
Going from Evolution to older Aurus series doesn´t seem like a really good idea to me, although Aurus Soft is a rubber used by many.
My bad, did not see that you already had FX-P. Well, Yasaka Rakza 7 is still very much used my many people even if it is also older. Many people at my club uses Aurus and Aurus Soft. Or perhaps Andro Rasanter R42 :) I used both this and V42 variant and they were good rubbers. I'd reccomend Rasant Beat butit is discontinued, sadly
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rub
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Sep 2022
2,179
2,224
8,944
I want something a bit more aggressive, which still has spin and a bit of control. Sorry, it was my mistake – I accidentally posted it too early.
How does the MX-P work for you on BH, just as a comparison I mean?
You like it or it's too fast etc?
Personally I would recommend some coaching on your BH and save the money you would spend on a new rubber.
I don't know your level but the FX-P on a 7 ply blade should be plenty aggressive I'd say, unless you're really winning all your matches, not ever missing the table in drills and really need more help to be more dangerous there.
I think coaching would unleash more from your stroke with more long term benefit than anything else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rub
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Apr 2014
1,935
1,518
3,538
Read 3 reviews
save the money you would spend on a new rubber.
He said rubbers need to be changed after nearly a year of playing (who would disagree...), so while coaching is always a good idea money will have to be spent on rubbers anyway.

Around here, the price of an Evolution rubber will buy you two lessons btw - and that´s not the best available coaches ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rub and Haito
Top