delaying the straightening of the arm

This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Well-Known Member
May 2011
1,213
1,314
3,207
Yeah, I've been toying around with it a bit, it seems that going to the backswing position with the arm bent is better than having the arm straightened - it seems to make for a more powerful "snap to salute" at the end. I think zeio's explanation is probably what is happening - if there's less delay between the straightening and the contraction it allows the contraction to become even stronger. Otherwise the arm stays in a straightened position for too long and that "stored" energy is lost.

Kinda like the example of half squatting before a jump. It's more powerful if you go into that half squat just before you jump, rather than staying in the half squat for too long a period of time.

You don't really need to worry about that. Think about why the half squat makes the jump better. The muscles that perform the jump, mostly the quads, cannot generate any more useful force once your feet leave the ground. That's why it's essential for the force to be as strong as possible during the upward phase before your feet leave the ground, and squatting gives your quads more time to ramp up its force so that when your body starts going upwards they're already almost fully engaged. That's not as much of an issue in TT, as your arm will always have an anchor to exert force from. The only time your arm can't generate more force is when the ball comes at you too fast, in which case you certainly won't have time to delay the straightening of your arm.

You've done regular squats, right? Does doing a bit of a "dip" right before you push up make the squat easier? Heck no! Think of a TT loop more like a soccer kick. The relevant muscles are already at their maximum "counter" position (i.e extended thigh and flexed knee) near the beginning of the forward swing. Of note, just like TT, the maximum "counter" position isn't achieved at the very start of the forward swing, merely near the start of it, because the action of the forward swing actually helps achieve the maximum "counter" position just like how the start of a TT forward swing naturally straightens out the elbow.

With both strokes the legs and hips are the major movers for sure. However the arm is also a major amplifier of that initial impulse and can be quite important imo...

I'm not sure the exact mechanics of it, but staying bent during the backswing and only straightening during the forward swing followed by contracting it during contact seems to give me a significant amount of extra acceleration somehow.... It does seem to "concentrate" the power better, by delaying this straightening of the arm.

Maybe what you're saying also contributes, that the shorter amount of delay between straightening and contraction actually helps to concentrate the power better and reduce power leaks.

The mechanic is the conservation of momentum. Since there's a combination of linear and rotational movement in a TT swing, both linear momentum and angular momentum come into play. You go from a big mass moving (basically your whole body) to a small mass moving (just your forearm/hand/racket), a big radius rotation (centered at your body) to a small radius rotation (centered at your elbow), and the still moving object (your forearm/hand/racket) will necessarily have to increase its velocity in order for momentum to be conserved.

It's the same for achieving a spinnier service. Stop everything from moving except your wrist shortly before the impact and your racket will move at a much faster speed.

NO! if the paddle is still accelerating at impact then it hasn't reached the maximum speed and the maximum speed. Any acceleration acceleration after impact is wasted energy and will delay recovery as now you have to decelerate the paddle. You want to hit the ball with the maximum paddle speed and that occurs when the acceleration is zero. This is simple calculus. The trick is how thinly you hit the ball so you can make the optimal ratio of speed and spin.


Myths.
Acceleration means nothing if the paddle isn't moving fast so it has momentum and energy.
In motion, the acceleration leads velocity and velocity leads position.

Wrong, that's only if you want maximum speed, like flat hitting. You want to accelerate through the impact if you're looping. This prolongs dwell time, which increases control and spin. You don't need maximum acceleration, of course, but you want to be accelerating when looping. The balance between maximum acceleration (occurs at the beginning of the swing) and maximum speed (second half of the swing) depends on the shot.

For example, have you ever tried to loop a half-long ball that barely falls off the table wide to your FH side near the net? You need maximum control and spin to land this delicate shot, especially if you don't want it to be high and easily countered. The way to do is to loop the ball at very near the beginning of your swing. This is the same as when you roll a ball off the table and try to loop it. Try doing it with a big backswing. You can't. You need to loop it at near the beginning of your forward swing. I think you understand some Chinese, right? Maybe try this video to see the practical application of some of my points.

 
This user has no status.
Just wanna share this old video

Maze is using the completely bent arm chicken wing stroke (at no point does he straighten the arm) - so it's not even a straight arm loop (the focus of this discussion).

Ma Long appears to straighten fully during the backswing in this video at least.

Zhang Jike actually keeps it bent during the backswing and only straightens it during the forward swing - see short below.

 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Well-Known Member
Nov 2020
1,072
788
4,035
On further analysis it appears Ma Long also delays the straightening to just before the forward swing starts - the delay is just not as drastic as what Zhang Jike is doing.
As he back-swings, the elbow-angle stays constant for a long time. The lower-arm appears to go down, but that is only because the upper-arm goes back so far. That is the 1st time I realized that. Thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blahness
This user has no status.
There are two other issues with straightening during the backswing.

One, it's wasted energy. Your arm will naturally straighten as your backswing nears its end and your body movement/rotation starts to slow down so long as you keep your elbow relaxed, so there is no need to actively straighten it. Two, and I think it's the most important, if a ball comes unexpectedly fast or toward your body and you need to shorten your swing, you may not be able to do so if you're actively forcing your forearm in the opposite direction.

This leads to IMO the most important point, which is just to keep the elbow tucked to the side and keep the joint relaxed. Don't worry about straightening or bending the elbow, let gravity and your own body's momentum do the work.
I think point no.2 is quite good - having the arm mostly bent during the majority of the backswing allows for more adjustability of the stroke to unexpected fast balls, because you can even choose to not straighten the arm at all from the backswing to gain more time and space to hit the ball - which will be useful especially against jamming strokes towards the elbow region.
 
Top