Ma Long Illegal Serve in Detail

What do you think, vote below and leave a comment on your decision

  • Legal

    Votes: 14 70.0%
  • Illegal

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Still unsure

    Votes: 4 20.0%

  • Total voters
    20

Dan

says Lots of updates being made on the site, thanks for all...

Dan

says Lots of updates being made on the site, thanks for all...
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Administrator
Aug 2010
7,129
5,207
17,489
Read 76 reviews
Okay, so we had the huge debate about whether Xu Xin's serve was illegal. Now we have a whole new discussion with Ma Long's service. Watch the video below, is the serve legal?

What do you think?

Long+Ma+16th+Asian+Games+Day+6+Table+Tennis+BvNn8T0xT7_l.jpg

Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images AsiaPac



 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Active Member
Apr 2011
676
42
719
I have no idea because the serve looks fine for me. To me, the fault should called by the umpire on the other side if Ma long's serve is illegal.

What I'm feel is that there should a guideline for a umpire, who should pay attention and call the fault for the serve by depends on which side of the player is serving. Since I found that you just can't judge all the serve just from one side at all.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Active Member
Sep 2011
913
66
1,009
Read 4 reviews
I've said this many times. You guys are confusing the paddle with the ball. The Chinese Service hides the stroke of the ball until point of contact so that a player can't use their stroke to tell what the service is. They have to wait until the ball bounces to their side to register what the spin is giving the Chinese that split second to get ready for the third ball attack. My understanding is that the ump wasn't calling an illegal service because of the toss, but because it may have looked like he hid the ball from Ma and that's why Ma failed to return. The reality is that she couldn't have seen the ball to begin with and that in itself is a biased opinion toward calling a fault rather than a warning. If an Ump is not facing the server they have no right to call a fault or warning on the service.

This is the most biased rule in the game and because the ITTF stands behind their umps many umps take advantage of this. In the league and organization I plan on creating this will be dealt with via camera angles and a line ump. There are so many rules that I think the ITTF created just to disadvantage the Chinese from pulling ahead of us. In my opinion each rule since the 2000 Olympics has been a rule to hinder the Chinese dominance. It's sad really.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Jun 2011
3,095
1,277
5,264
Read 7 reviews
Well I watched it 5-6 times and I think Ma Lin could see the ball flight and also it was a good toss..
I think the server was legal and ok..
Also I dont think in the second serve he put some spin into it, its ridiculous and even if he did, it wouldnt affect the serve..
(I have tryed it, hehe)

So my opinion is that it was legal.
 
says Spin and more spin.
says Spin and more spin.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Moderator
Dec 2010
16,640
18,535
56,964
Read 11 reviews
I cannot see anything from the video but Ma Lin certainly does a damn good job of acting absolutely sure that there is something wrong with the serve. It looks like Ma Long's left arm is possibly in the way as the ball is dropping and that would qualify as against the rules. If there is any point where the ball is blocked by that left arm it would be against the rules. But all you can really see is Ma Lin's reaction.

In basketball a lot of the time a guy will fall down in this dramatic way and then get a call from a ref who might not have seen the play clearly. The refs sometimes call a foul simply because of the guy doing this whole big thing. And it definitely looks like Ma Lin does the Table Tennis version of flopping on the floor with arms flailing there. He has no intention of trying to get the ball on the table or seeing what happens to his return. His back is turned before his ball reaches the net.
 
Last edited:
says Spin and more spin.
says Spin and more spin.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Well-Known Member
Moderator
Dec 2010
16,640
18,535
56,964
Read 11 reviews
By the way, I don't know that Ma Lin would act like something was wrong with a serve unless there was something wrong with the serve. At least not like he does on that serve. So my guess is that there is something that he sees that we are unable to see on the video.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
🏆 Top 1% Commenter
Active Member
Sep 2011
913
66
1,009
Read 4 reviews
Carl, pay attention to the left side of the video. Right after the serve, but before Ma Lin touches the ball the Ref raises her hand to award him the point. He acted that way because he felt it was a bogus call as well. He obviously just wanted to play the point and was given a "cheap" point in his opinion. That is my understanding of the video. It was a bogus call and biased that an ump can even call it. I know that in the leagues I'm creating something will be done about crappy reffing and also I'm thinking video playback will be an option for the players when a ref has a bad call. It's in Tennis so I feel it should be in Table Tennis.
 
This user has no status.
This user has no status.
Member
Nov 2010
499
7
506
To be honest, a lot of people read the serve rule way too strictly, rules in general, and writing in general is rarely ever so concrete and unyielding. Pros because they have the time and put in the effort, they make their serves often as close to breaking the rule outright, without doing so.
 
Top