So I finally got to play people yesterday since starting this thread. In the interim I tried to prepare for that by speeding up the robot (increased throwing frequency and increased sweep frequency and increased the sweep angle).
My goal was "READ, PLAN, DO", but mainly, to WATCH what the other guy was doing.
The results were:
- READ: total failure. I am absolutely not able to "read" what the opponent might do, there is just not enough time. Even if I were to stop and watch I don't think I can tell where he is going to hit it.
- PLAN: here I had considerable success! Just watching them allowed me to see how they usually return a particular serve, for example. With that information, I would execute that serve and wait for the expected type of return. Surprisingly often the return was as expected! I don't consider this "reading" because it's not very dynamic, on-your-feet thinking, more of a "setup for expected results". Whatever - it was great.
- DO: with the additional time gained by some predictability, I was able to actually prepare for and execute certain shots. Backhand was still disappointing because even when expecting, and getting, a slow push to my BH, I couldn't bring myself to hit the loop. Very odd.
Net results: I beat a guy who had totally thrashed me the one time we played, and lost a nailbiter to another guy who had easily beaten me before. Coulda/shoulda won it. Both were higher rated players.
I had gone in expecting to lose, and almost wanting to lose (to be sure I am following the right principles instead of just trying to win) but the increased "watchfulness" seems to pay immediate dividends. The matches against these two guys felt TOTALLY different from last time. Because actually paying attention, showed me their patterns.
Next steps, of course: try to figure out this "READ" thing, and then try to force my muscles (or brain) to execute a shot according to plan, when I get the expected behavior, instead of playing the safe return (Grr!!).
Much thanks to all for opening up a whole new way of playing the game!