I think this is solid advice, generally. I have seen the development go fast on other players in the club that did start with tensioned rubbers, but it will be exciting to see if they hit a plateau. However, the path I have allready taken is a different one, and I think its even more important to not fall into the "equipment junkie"-trap where you change your equipment instead of working on developing your gamesense. I certainly have a large swing, and often fall back into a defensive game if the ball comes back because I dont have the time to recover to counter it (honestly, even Ma Long does this).
I guess there is just different paths. The first racket I got custom made for me in a specialist shop had very soft and very bouncy rubbers (Yasaka Rigan 2.0) which were not of good quality. On top of that, they were glued on a flexible blade that had hard outer layers, which made my first impression of these types of rubbers not so good because the rubbers would bottom out too easily, making the timing very hard. I struggled for a long time to control this setup, but I do think they gave me a sense of spin, and my blocking ability against flat smashes were good + I would have a lot of control on my own smashes.
Trying DHS Hurricane 3 Neo on forehand for 4 months was also very difficult, but I believe it taught me to hit with the body, even though I would overcompensate by "punching" the ball some times instead of bringing the forward force that is going into the ball from the rotation of the body. This is a common beginner mistake, as I have seen. Therefore, my attempt at Yasaka Rakza Z was a somewhat of a revelation for me.
Since my backhand stroke was simple -- I only did backhand drives and barely dont do much more to this day -- I stuck to the Yasaka Rigan because I could punch through the ball and soft rubbers like that works well with smash type hitting. Switching to Yasaka Mark V on backhand has been doing wonders for me to lift backspin balls with my backhand, chopping balls that go wide and deep, pushing very accurately and I am now learning how to chiquita flip. I also love serving with this rubber and my serves are actually my strongest suit because I do maybe 20 min serve practice 4-5 times per week.
The moral of the story is that there is a lot of history here. Since I started playing table tennis without having played any racket sport before at the age of 38, things go a bit slower for me, but there are definite progress in my game. I can see this from filming myself. This december I will have played table tennis for two years, which is a stretch of time that is difficult to grasp and to retell in an online forum.
Maybe you can see the trial and error pattern I have gone through with slight adjustments on equipment by this overview on equipment ...
Equipment history (2 years):
Stiga Offensive Classic, Yasaka Rigan, Yasaka Rigan
Stiga Offensive Classic, Hurricane 3 Neo, Hurricane 3 Neo
Stiga Offensive Classic, Hurricane 3 Neo, Yasaka Rigan
Stiga Offensive Classic, Yasaka Rakza Z, Yasaka Rigan
Stiga Offensive Classic, Yasaka Rakza Z, Nittaku Factive
Stiga Offensive Classic, Yasaka Rakza Z, Yasaka Mark V
Avalox P500, Yasaka Rakza Z, Yasaka Mark V
Training game 16. october 2023:
I am the dude in the white shoes