What was the best rubber for 1ply hinoki in your opinion? You played with chinese rubbers only? And did you play jpen?
Okay so just for context, I loveee 1-ply Hinoki with it's buttery-soft feeling. But I just feel I don't have the skill for them especially as I'm a looper. Also
@Wakkibatty and
@greenbeanmachine are wayyy more knowledgable than me for answering this question. But I'll share what I've found for sure and maybe it will be of some help ^_^
The blades I have tried:
- Pro Pro Moby 9mm, cpen
- Darker Speed 90 9mm, jpen
- Butterfly Senkoh 1 9mm, jpen
- Nittaku Miyabi 9mm, jpen
- No-name cheap one 8mm, cpen
The differences between them are like, a lot... But to keep things straightforward, the Moby/Speed90/Senkoh-1 were more alike, the Miyabi and Noname 8mm felt way different. Softer and I could always feel more vibrations on those than the former 3. The Noname 8mm was heaps slower than the rest, and the Miyabi was a bit slower than the former 3.
The rubbers I liked the most were those with soft sponges, with little catapult. Palio AK47 was nice but I didn't like that it had no tackiness. I went to Nexxus EL Pro 43 and it was so so good, but I bottom'd out way too much. PowerplayX 38deg and 39deg (boosted), Mercury II Soft (boosted, bottom'd out too much though like the Nexxus), H3 Neo 39deg (boosted) -- all were so nice and paired extremely well with hinoki's soft feel with no flex.
All the "tensors" I tried (T05FX, T80, D05, K3, G05, Fastarc G1, MXP) worked super well, they were just way too fast for me. I imagine someone would be able to practice and get used to it. Like arguably the best 1-ply hinoki playerl; Ryu Seung-min -- in a recent video he still recommends Tenergy for 1-ply hinoki.
Classic/Control rubbers like Sriver and Andro Good felt nice too, but not as good as the softer ones I mentioned above.
Hinoki gives plenty of power, so using the classic, soft, or chinese tacky rubbers helps tame that power while giving more of that yummy butter-soft feeling of 1-ply Hinoki. That's the main reason I enjoyed the softer sponge rubbers, but also because my playstyle is around looping. Hinoki excels if your playstyle is centered around hitting and drives. Especially with a tensor! Hits are SO powerful.
The biggest thing for any of the rubbers was to keep it 2.1mm or less, especially if I was boosting it. For some reason it doesn't let the blade effect of a Hinoki through -- and that's the biggest thing compared to multi-ply blades where they can flex.
@Wakkibatty explained this
here.