Thanks a lot for replying,
@hipnotic. I just inspected the blade. The sealer on the wood is hardly "sticky" anymore, but it was semi-"sticky" for a few weeks after sealing it...
It is not an oil based sealer, it is a water based sealer by GEWO (see picture). However it is rather old as I had it in my drawer for a few years before using it. I did use it as supposed to (more or less

. Back side of the bottle says to let it dry for at least 4 hours; not quite sure if I made it to the 4 hour mark before applying the next layer...could have been 3 hours).
While it is hardly "sticky" anymore, you can clearly see and feel the smears where I used the sponge to brush around and apply the sealer. The wood now feels (and looks) raw instead of smooth as it was once before.
Not sure if one can see the smears in the picture, but here are some anyway. Any suggestions?
postimg.cc