Now regarding the inconsistencies on your serve
Just a note on this. I played two singles matches against OldSchool and 3 doubles matches with and against, and done a some extra training drills. I have not seen him miss a serve in any of those matches or the training drills. And I definitely struggled a lot with his serves because they are definitely good.
One thing I can say for sure and from 1st hand experience for OldSchool and 42&BP: their technique is way higher than their level even if their level is higher than they let on.
Der_ swore OldSchool was 2000 and sandbagging in our doubles and OldSchool and I actually came really close to pulling out the first doubles match vs Der_ and PPH who are probably a combined 900 points higher than the OCDCarl and OSPH rating wise. And I am pathetic at doubles so don't blame me for us doing well.
But these two guys (OSPH and 42&BP) who are old men like me and learned decades ago when kids, took a 30 year break and are coming back to it as if from a past life. The result is, the technique is there. They have excellent technique. But they have things holding them back like injuries and fitness level or underperforming on the money points. And yet they still play like wily old veterans.
So don't sleep on them.
I may not have ever lost a match to 42&BP but I still think he is better than me. And when we do serve and receive drills he gives me some pointers that are as good as what I get from many coaches because he sees and knows the game.
I split matches with OSPH. And even though, my win in the second match was convincing (if I could remember the numbers they would still be besides they point), he really beat himself. In that match, all I did was keep the ball on the table and he simple did not. He gave me so many free points on empty serves where I was simply looking to set up my third ball. So it was not at all representative of the standard of play I saw from him when we were doing serve and receive drills or any drills for that matter.
So here the issue is that the technique is solid. More match simulation training for OSPH and he will jump 3-500 points in level.
For 42&BP, he actually already has that. Me and him beat a doubles pair where the higher rated player is 1900+ and the lower rated player is a hair lower level than me. It went the full distance. We won at deuce in the 5th. [SpyPhone spell check tried to turn that into DUNCE in the 5th hahahaha] but it had much more to with BackPains than with the OCDCarl.
In doubles 42&BP can do more because he has more space between points so the back and shoulder don't hamper him quite the same way. And man he is good at setting up points in doubles. Even I felt like I could play doubles with him as my teammate.
Sent from Inside The Chamber of Secrets by Patronus